Thread: problem with subselect
Hi, I have this : SELECT date_trunc('month', f.date_creation) as mois, sum(f.montant_ttc / d.taux) as facture, (SELECT sum(f2.montant_ttc/ d2.taux) as facture2 FROM facture AS f2 JOIN devise AS d2 USING (id_devise) WHERE date_trunc('month',f2.date_creation) <= date_trunc('month', f.date_creation)) FROM facture AS f JOIN devise AS d USING (id_devise) GROUP BY date_trunc('month', f.date_creation) which does not work... telling me that "Sub-SELECT uses un-GROUPed attribute f.date_creation from outer query" Which is not really true, but some way is... What I want is to get the sum of the month, and the sum of the month and the previous. If someone has a clue, something, anything... :) -- Mathieu Arnold
> > I have this : > > SELECT date_trunc('month', f.date_creation) as mois, > sum(f.montant_ttc / d.taux) as facture, > (SELECT sum(f2.montant_ttc / d2.taux) as facture2 > FROM facture AS f2 JOIN devise AS d2 USING (id_devise) > WHERE date_trunc('month', f2.date_creation) > <= date_trunc('month', f.date_creation)) > FROM facture AS f JOIN devise AS d USING (id_devise) > GROUP BY date_trunc('month', f.date_creation) > > which does not work... telling me that > > "Sub-SELECT uses un-GROUPed attribute f.date_creation from outer query" > Which is not really true, but some way is... > > What I want is to get the sum of the month, and the sum of the month and > the previous. > > If someone has a clue, something, anything... :) > Try ... GROUP BY mois ; Regards, Christoph
--En cette belle journée de vendredi 7 mars 2003 14:15 +0100, -- Christoph Haller <ch@rodos.fzk.de> écrivait : |> |> I have this : |> |> SELECT date_trunc('month', f.date_creation) as mois, |> sum(f.montant_ttc / d.taux) as facture, |> (SELECT sum(f2.montant_ttc / d2.taux) as facture2 |> FROM facture AS f2 JOIN devise AS d2 USING (id_devise) |> WHERE date_trunc('month', f2.date_creation) |> <= date_trunc('month', f.date_creation)) |> FROM facture AS f JOIN devise AS d USING (id_devise) |> GROUP BY date_trunc('month', f.date_creation) |> |> which does not work... telling me that |> |> "Sub-SELECT uses un-GROUPed attribute f.date_creation from outer | query" |> Which is not really true, but some way is... |> |> What I want is to get the sum of the month, and the sum of the month | and |> the previous. |> |> If someone has a clue, something, anything... :) |> | Try | ... GROUP BY mois ; Already tried, not working either. -- Mathieu Arnold
> |> SELECT date_trunc('month', f.date_creation) as mois, > |> sum(f.montant_ttc / d.taux) as facture, > |> (SELECT sum(f2.montant_ttc / d2.taux) as facture2 > |> FROM facture AS f2 JOIN devise AS d2 USING (id_devise) > |> WHERE date_trunc('month', f2.date_creation) > |> <=3D date_trunc('month', f.date_creation)) > |> FROM facture AS f JOIN devise AS d USING (id_devise) > |> GROUP BY date_trunc('month', f.date_creation) > |>=20 > |> which does not work... telling me that > |>=20 > |> "Sub-SELECT uses un-GROUPed attribute f.date_creation from outer > | query" > |> Which is not really true, but some way is... > |>=20 > |> What I want is to get the sum of the month, and the sum of the month > | and > |> the previous. > |>=20 > |> If someone has a clue, something, anything... :) > |>=20 > | Try > | ... GROUP BY mois ; > > Already tried, not working either. > I should have had a closer look: The WHERE clause is causing the error. I can't see any quick solution, but what often helped me is First try to word the query as a view and do the GROUPing then on the view. Regards, Christoph
Mathieu, > SELECT date_trunc('month', f.date_creation) as mois, > sum(f.montant_ttc / d.taux) as facture, > (SELECT sum(f2.montant_ttc / d2.taux) as facture2 > FROM facture AS f2 JOIN devise AS d2 USING (id_devise) > WHERE date_trunc('month', f2.date_creation) > <= date_trunc('month', f.date_creation)) > FROM facture AS f JOIN devise AS d USING (id_devise) > GROUP BY date_trunc('month', f.date_creation) > "Sub-SELECT uses un-GROUPed attribute f.date_creation from outer query" > Which is not really true, but some way is... Hmmm ... this looks like a minor parser bug. What Postgres version are you using? > What I want is to get the sum of the month, and the sum of the month and > the previous. > > If someone has a clue, something, anything... :) Sure. Try putting the sub-select in the FROM clause, instead of the SELECT; that should un-confuse the parser about the grouping. -- Josh Berkus Aglio Database Solutions San Francisco
Josh Berkus <josh@agliodbs.com> writes: >> "Sub-SELECT uses un-GROUPed attribute f.date_creation from outer query" >> Which is not really true, but some way is... > Hmmm ... this looks like a minor parser bug. No, it's operating as designed. Note the comments in CVS tip parse_agg.c: * NOTE: we recognize grouping expressions in the main query, but only* grouping Vars in subqueries. For example, this willbe rejected,* although it could be allowed:* SELECT* (SELECT x FROM bar where y = (foo.a + foo.b))* FROM foo* GROUP BY a + b;* The difficulty is the need to account for different sublevels_up.* Thisappears to require a whole custom version of equal(), which is* way more pain than the feature seems worth. Previous versions implemented the check for ungrouped vars a little differently, but the net effect was the same. (Given that SQL99 allows only a simple column reference as a GROUP BY element, this isn't a spec violation, merely a limitation on how far we are willing to extend the spec.) There are a number of straightforward ways to rewrite the query to avoid this, but I can't help wondering whether the basic approach isn't wrong. The subselect seems an ugly and inefficient way to do it, because it's re-executing the entire join for each group ... but I can't quite put my finger on a better way ... regards, tom lane