Re: Unix-domain socket support on Windows - Mailing list pgsql-hackers

On 2/12/20 3:32 AM, Peter Eisentraut wrote:
> Here is another patch set to enable this functionality.
>
> 0001 enables Unix-domain sockets on Windows, but leaves them turned
> off by default at run time, using the mechanism introduced by
> a9cff89f7e. This is relatively straightforward, except perhaps some
> aesthetic questions about how these different configuration bits are
> distributed around the various files.
>
> 0002 deals with pg_upgrade.  It preserves the existing behavior of not
> using Unix-domain sockets on Windows.  This could perhaps be enhanced
> later by either adding a command-line option or a run-time test.  It's
> too complicated right now.
>
> 0003 deals with how initdb should initialize postgresql.conf and
> pg_hba.conf.  It introduces a run-time test similar to how we detect
> presence of IPv6.  After I wrote this patch, I have come to think that
> this is overkill and we should just always leave the "local" line in
> pg_hba.conf even if there is no run-time support in the OS.  (I think
> the reason we do the run-time test for IPv6 is that we need it to
> parse the IPv6 addresses in pg_hba.conf, but there is no analogous
> requirement for Unix-domain sockets.)  This patch is optional in any
> case.
>
> 0004 fixes a bug in the pg_upgrade test.sh script that was exposed by
> these changes.
>
> 0005 fixes up some issues in the test suites.  Right now, the TAP
> tests are hardcoded to not use Unix-domain sockets on Windows, where
> as pg_regress keys off HAVE_UNIX_SOCKETS, which is no longer a useful
> distinguisher.  The change is to not use Unix-domain sockets for all
> the tests by default on Windows (the previous behavior) but give an
> option to use them.  At the moment, I would consider running the test
> suites with Unix-domain sockets enabled as experimental, but that's
> only because of various issues in the test setups.  For instance,
> there is an issue in the comment of pg_regress.c remove_temp() that
> I'm not sure how to address.  Also, the TAP tests don't seem to work
> because of some path issues.  I figured I'd call time on fiddling with
> this for now and ship the patches.
>

I have tested this on drongo/fairywren and it works fine. The patches
apply cleanly (with a bit of fuzz) and a full buildfarm run is happy in
both cases.

Unfortunately I don't have a Windows machine that's young enough to
support git master and old enough not to support Unix Domain sockets, so
i can't test that with socket-enabled binaries.

On inspection the patches seem fine.

Let's commit this and keep working on the pg_upgrade and test issues.


cheers


andrew

-- 
Andrew Dunstan                https://www.2ndQuadrant.com
PostgreSQL Development, 24x7 Support, Remote DBA, Training & Services