Re: How to use a cross column exclude constraint - Mailing list pgsql-novice

From awolchute@tutanota.com
Subject Re: How to use a cross column exclude constraint
Date
Msg-id NAJp2p2--3-2@tutanota.com
Whole thread Raw
In response to How to use a cross column exclude constraint  (awolchute@tutanota.com)
Responses Re: How to use a cross column exclude constraint
List pgsql-novice
Hi,

What does this part of your annotation mean: "slot {check slot in (1,2); not null}, {PK: (edge_id, slot)}, {Unique: node_id}]"? The whole Node-Edge part is a bit fuzzy for me.

I have written the following schema:

-- node
CREATE TABLE api_endpoints (
  id UUID PRIMARY KEY,
  api_endoint_edge_id UUID REFERENCES api_endpoint_edges (id),
  UNIQUE (id, api_endpoint_edge_id), -- did I interpret this correctly?
  ...   
);

-- edge
CREATE TABLE api_endpoint_edges (
  id UUID PRIMARY KEY,
  ...  -- ton of data 
);

-- node-edge, how should i name this table? is just dropping the pluralization readable?
CREATE TABLE api_endpoint_edge (
  id UUID PRIMARY KEY,
  api_endoint_id UUID REFERENCES api_endpoints (id),
  api_endoint_edge_id UUID PRIMARY KEY REFERENCES api_endpoints (id),
  -- what is slot?
);

Thank you for helping me get started with Postgres!


Aug 24, 2022, 13:47 by david.g.johnston@gmail.com:
On Wednesday, August 24, 2022, <awolchute@tutanota.com> wrote:
Hi,

Thank you for the insight!

How would you go about modeling my problem correctly?

The domain constraints are:
- there are many "records"
- there are 1:1 links between "records", and the links (table) contain a lot of information about the link (so adding a record_id (fk) to the records table would also add a ton of columns).
- the links are bidirectional
- each "record" can be linked with exactly one "record", so a record linking to another does not allow the record being referenced to be in any other link either.
- a graph of records and their connections (links) must be efficiently queried / formed

Node: [node_id PK, edge_id {FK edge.edge_id}, {Unique: node_id, edge_id)]
Edge: [edge_id PK, …]
Node-Edge: [(node_id, edge_id) {FK node.node_id, node.edge_id}, slot {check slot in (1,2); not null}, {PK: (edge_id, slot)}, {Unique: node_id}]

That doesn’t enforce “not zero” or missing records, which is possible but generally a pain, but does enforce that a node may have at most one edge, and each edge has at most two nodes.

With a deferred not null constraint on node.esge_id I think you can solve prevent missing links problem, assuming you always add nodes in pairs.  You’d do so ething similar with edge.edge_id if you wanted to avoid dangling edges (edges without nodes).

David J.



pgsql-novice by date:

Previous
From: mahendrakar s
Date:
Subject: Re: best way to apply and work on the patches of the pg community
Next
From: "David G. Johnston"
Date:
Subject: Re: How to use a cross column exclude constraint