Re: PoC: Partial sort - Mailing list pgsql-hackers

On Sat, Dec 28, 2013 at 9:28 PM, Alexander Korotkov <aekorotkov@gmail.com> wrote:

On Tue, Dec 24, 2013 at 6:02 AM, Andreas Karlsson <andreas@proxel.se> wrote:

Attached revision of patch implements partial sort usage in merge joins.

I'm looking forward to doing a bit of testing on this patch. I think it is a really useful feature to get a bit more out of existing indexes.

I was about to test it tonight, but I'm having trouble getting the patch to compile... I'm really wondering which compiler you are using as it seems you're declaring your variables in some strange places.. See nodeSort.c line 101. These variables are declared after there has been an if statement in the same scope. That's not valid in C. (The patch did however apply without any complaints).

Here's a list of the errors I get when compiling with visual studios on windows.

"D:\Postgres\c\pgsql.sln" (default target) (1) ->

"D:\Postgres\c\postgres.vcxproj" (default target) (2) ->

(ClCompile target) ->

  src\backend\executor\nodeSort.c(101): error C2275: 'Sort' : illegal use of this type as an expression [D:\Postgres\c\postgres.vcxproj]

  src\backend\executor\nodeSort.c(101): error C2065: 'plannode' : undeclared identifier [D:\Postgres\c\postgres.vcxproj]

  src\backend\executor\nodeSort.c(102): error C2275: 'PlanState' : illegal use of this type as an expression [D:\Postgres\c\postgres.vcxproj]

  src\backend\executor\nodeSort.c(102): error C2065: 'outerNode' : undeclared identifier [D:\Postgres\c\postgres.vcxproj]

  src\backend\executor\nodeSort.c(103): error C2275: 'TupleDesc' : illegal use of this type as an expression [D:\Postgres\c\postgres.vcxproj]

  src\backend\executor\nodeSort.c(103): error C2146: syntax error : missing ';' before identifier 'tupDesc' [D:\Postgres\c\postgres.vcxproj]

  src\backend\executor\nodeSort.c(103): error C2065: 'tupDesc' : undeclared identifier [D:\Postgres\c\postgres.vcxproj]

  src\backend\executor\nodeSort.c(120): error C2065: 'outerNode' : undeclared identifier [D:\Postgres\c\postgres.vcxproj]

  src\backend\executor\nodeSort.c(121): error C2065: 'tupDesc' : undeclared identifier [D:\Postgres\c\postgres.vcxproj]

  src\backend\executor\nodeSort.c(121): error C2065: 'outerNode' : undeclared identifier [D:\Postgres\c\postgres.vcxproj]

  src\backend\executor\nodeSort.c(125): error C2065: 'tupDesc' : undeclared identifier [D:\Postgres\c\postgres.vcxproj]

  src\backend\executor\nodeSort.c(126): error C2065: 'plannode' : undeclared identifier [D:\Postgres\c\postgres.vcxproj]

  src\backend\executor\nodeSort.c(126): error C2223: left of '->numCols' must point to struct/union [D:\Postgres\c\postgres.vcxproj]

  src\backend\executor\nodeSort.c(127): error C2065: 'plannode' : undeclared identifier [D:\Postgres\c\postgres.vcxproj]

  src\backend\executor\nodeSort.c(127): error C2223: left of '->sortColIdx' must point to struct/union [D:\Postgres\c\postgres.vcxproj]

  src\backend\executor\nodeSort.c(128): error C2065: 'plannode' : undeclared identifier [D:\Postgres\c\postgres.vcxproj]

  src\backend\executor\nodeSort.c(128): error C2223: left of '->sortOperators' must point to struct/union [D:\Postgres\c\postgres.vcxproj]

  src\backend\executor\nodeSort.c(129): error C2065: 'plannode' : undeclared identifier [D:\Postgres\c\postgres.vcxproj]

  src\backend\executor\nodeSort.c(129): error C2223: left of '->collations' must point to struct/union [D:\Postgres\c\postgres.vcxproj]

  src\backend\executor\nodeSort.c(130): error C2065: 'plannode' : undeclared identifier [D:\Postgres\c\postgres.vcxproj]

  src\backend\executor\nodeSort.c(130): error C2223: left of '->nullsFirst' must point to struct/union [D:\Postgres\c\postgres.vcxproj]

  src\backend\executor\nodeSort.c(132): error C2198: 'tuplesort_begin_heap' : too few arguments for call [D:\Postgres\c\postgres.vcxproj]

  src\backend\executor\nodeSort.c(143): error C2065: 'outerNode' : undeclared identifier [D:\Postgres\c\postgres.vcxproj]

  src\backend\executor\nodeSort.c(167): error C2065: 'tupDesc' : undeclared identifier [D:\Postgres\c\postgres.vcxproj]

    13 Warning(s)

    24 Error(s)