Re: PG "Users" page?

From: Jonathan S. Katz
Subject: Re: PG "Users" page?
Date: ,
(view: Whole thread, Raw)
In response to: Re: PG "Users" page?  (Magnus Hagander)
Responses: Re: PG "Users" page?  (Damien Clochard)
List: pgsql-advocacy

Tree view

PG "Users" page?  (Justin Clift, )
 Re: PG "Users" page?  (Dave Page, )
  Re: PG "Users" page?  (Justin Clift, )
   Re: PG "Users" page?  (Justin Clift, )
   Re: PG "Users" page?  (Dave Page, )
    Re: [MASSMAIL]Re: PG "Users" page?  ("Gilberto Castillo", )
  Re: PG "Users" page?  (Magnus Hagander, )
   Re: PG "Users" page?  ("Jonathan S. Katz", )
    Re: PG "Users" page?  (Damien Clochard, )
     Re: PG "Users" page?  (Petr Jelinek, )
     Re: PG "Users" page?  (Justin Clift, )

On Sep 12, 2016, at 8:49 AM, Magnus Hagander <> wrote:

On Sun, Sep 11, 2016 at 6:14 PM, Dave Page <> wrote:

> On 11 Sep 2016, at 16:55, Justin Clift <> wrote:
> Hi us,
> Just noticed that our Featured Users page has “Sun Microsystems” listed:
>  (Under “Technology” at the bottom)
> Should we update that to say “Oracle” :D … or maybe just nuke that entry?

That page is completely unmaintained. I proposed removing it a couple of years back, but was met with strong objections coupled with a complete lack of volunteers to actually do the work to keep it up to date.

I strongly feel it should be removed still - it is probably responsible for 25% of emails to webmaster@ from random companies requesting inclusion.

Given that it really isn't being maintained, and that it actually takes a decent amount of time for somebody to maintain it in a way to make it actually *valuable* to visitors, I'll give a strong +1 for removing it.


If we want just a list of users, we could do that and make it self-service (meaning you just sign up and fill in your details - like we have for professional services). But that's something very different from being a featured user.

+1 - but it goes back to Dave’s point of lack of criteria for how users get listed, even if we make it self-signup.  We would probably want to moderate it similar to the self-published content to avoid spam, etc.

pgsql-advocacy by date:

From: "Jonathan S. Katz"
Subject: Re: PG "Users" page?
From: Josh Berkus
Subject: Re: DRAFT 9.6 release -- is Final