On 21/09/2020 17:19, Andrey M. Borodin wrote:
>> 21 сент. 2020 г., в 18:29, Andrey M. Borodin <x4mmm@yandex-team.ru> написал(а):
>>
>> It was a conscious decision with incorrect motivation. I was thinking that it will help to reduce number of "false
positive"inspecting right pages. But now I see that:
>> 1. There should be no such "false positives" that we can avoid
>> 2. Valid rightlinks could help to do amcheck verification in future
>
> Well, point number 2 here is invalid. There exist one leaf page p, so that if we start traversing rightlink from p we
willreach all leaf pages. But we practically have no means to find this page. This makes rightlinks not very helpful in
amcheckfor GiST.
Well, if you store all the right links in a hash table or something, you
can "connect the dots" after you have scanned all the pages to see that
the chain is unbroken. Probably would not be worth the trouble, since
the rightlinks are not actually needed after concurrent scans have
completed.
> But for consistency I think it worth to install them.
I agree. I did some testing with your patch. It seems that the
rightlinks are still not always set. I didn't try to debug why.
I wrote a couple of 'pageinspect' function to inspect GiST pages for
this. See attached. I then created a test table and index like this:
create table points (p point);
insert into points select point(x,y) from generate_series(-2000, 2000)
x, generate_series(-2000, 2000) y;
create index points_idx on points using gist (p);
And this is what the root page looks like:
postgres=# select * from gist_page_items(get_raw_page('points_idx', 0));
itemoffset | ctid | itemlen
------------+---------------+---------
1 | (27891,65535) | 40
2 | (55614,65535) | 40
3 | (83337,65535) | 40
4 | (97019,65535) | 40
(4 rows)
And the right links on the next level:
postgres=# select * from (VALUES (27891), (55614), (83337), (97019)) b
(blkno), lateral gist_page_opaque_info(get_raw_page('points_idx', blkno));
blkno | lsn | nsn | rightlink | flags
-------+-----+-----+------------+-------
27891 | 0/1 | 0/0 | 4294967295 | {}
55614 | 0/1 | 0/0 | 4294967295 | {}
83337 | 0/1 | 0/0 | 27891 | {}
97019 | 0/1 | 0/0 | 55614 | {}
(4 rows)
I expected there to be only one page with invalid right link, but there
are two.
- Heikki
