Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4

From: Tom Lane
Subject: Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4
Date: ,
Msg-id: 29080.1236821556@sss.pgh.pa.us
(view: Whole thread, Raw)
In response to: Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  ("Kevin Grittner")
Responses: Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  ("Jignesh K. Shah")
List: pgsql-performance

Tree view

Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  ("Jignesh K. Shah", )
 Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  ("Kevin Grittner", )
  Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  ("Jignesh K. Shah", )
   Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  ("Kevin Grittner", )
  Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Tom Lane, )
   Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  ("Jignesh K. Shah", )
    Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Simon Riggs, )
     Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  ("Jignesh K. Shah", )
     Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  ("Jignesh K. Shah", )
      Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Simon Riggs, )
       Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  ("Jignesh K. Shah", )
        Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Simon Riggs, )
        Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Gregory Stark, )
         Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Scott Carey, )
          Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  ("Jignesh K. Shah", )
  Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Scott Carey, )
   Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Tom Lane, )
    Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  ("Jignesh K. Shah", )
     Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (decibel, )
      Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  ("Jignesh K. Shah", )
       Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Josh Berkus, )
    Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Scott Carey, )
     Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  ("Jignesh K. Shah", )
      Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  ("Kevin Grittner", )
      Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Scott Carey, )
       Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  ("Jignesh K. Shah", )
        Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Gregory Stark, )
         Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  ("Jignesh K. Shah", )
          Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Gregory Stark, )
         Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (decibel, )
        Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Gregory Stark, )
        Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  ("Jignesh K. Shah", )
         Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  ("Kevin Grittner", )
          Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Scott Carey, )
           Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  ("Jignesh K. Shah", )
         Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  ("Kevin Grittner", )
         Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  ("Jignesh K. Shah", )
          Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Scott Carey, )
           Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Scott Carey, )
            Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  ("Jignesh K. Shah", )
          Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  ("Jignesh K. Shah", )
           Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (decibel, )
            Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  ("Jignesh K. Shah", )
             Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Gregory Stark, )
              Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  ("Jignesh K. Shah", )
      Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Greg Smith, )
   Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  ("Jignesh K. Shah", )
    Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Scott Carey, )
    Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Greg Smith, )
     Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Scott Carey, )
      Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Robert Haas, )
       Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Tom Lane, )
        Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Scott Carey, )
        Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  ("Kevin Grittner", )
         Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Scott Carey, )
         Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (, )
          Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  ("Kevin Grittner", )
           Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  ("Kevin Grittner", )
            Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Scott Carey, )
        Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Heikki Linnakangas, )
         Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Tom Lane, )
          Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Scott Carey, )
          Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Simon Riggs, )
         Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Matthew Wakeling, )
          Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Simon Riggs, )
           Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Matthew Wakeling, )
            Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Simon Riggs, )
             Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Matthew Wakeling, )
             Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  ("Jignesh K. Shah", )
              Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Matthew Wakeling, )
               Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Simon Riggs, )
           Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Tom Lane, )
            Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Simon Riggs, )
           Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Scott Carey, )
            Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Matthew Wakeling, )
             Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Tom Lane, )
             Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Scott Carey, )
             Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Simon Riggs, )
          Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Heikki Linnakangas, )
           Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Matthew Wakeling, )
       Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Scott Carey, )
        Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Robert Haas, )
         Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  ("Jignesh K. Shah", )
          Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Robert Haas, )
           Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Scott Carey, )
            Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Robert Haas, )
             Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Scott Carey, )
              Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Alvaro Herrera, )
               Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Alvaro Herrera, )
                Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Alvaro Herrera, )
                 Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  ("Jignesh K. Shah", )
                  Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Robert Haas, )
                   Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  ("Jignesh K. Shah", )
           Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  ("Jignesh K. Shah", )
         Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Bruce Momjian, )
          Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Scott Carey, )
           Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Bruce Momjian, )
         Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Scott Carey, )
      Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Greg Smith, )
     8.4 Performance improvements: was Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  ("Jignesh K. Shah", )
      Re: 8.4 Performance improvements: was Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Gregory Stark, )
      Re: 8.4 Performance improvements: was Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Gregory Stark, )
       Re: 8.4 Performance improvements: was Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Alan Stange, )
        Re: 8.4 Performance improvements: was Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Tom Lane, )
         Re: 8.4 Performance improvements: was Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Gregory Stark, )
          Re: 8.4 Performance improvements: was Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Tom Lane, )
           Re: 8.4 Performance improvements: was Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Robert Haas, )
            Re: 8.4 Performance improvements: was Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Gregory Stark, )
            Re: 8.4 Performance improvements: was Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Tom Lane, )
           Re: 8.4 Performance improvements: was Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Bruce Momjian, )
            Re: 8.4 Performance improvements: was Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Bruce Momjian, )
      Re: 8.4 Performance improvements: was Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Greg Smith, )
   Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  ("Kevin Grittner", )
    Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Grzegorz Jaśkiewicz, )
     Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  ("Kevin Grittner", )
      Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Ron, )
     Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Gregory Stark, )
      Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Scott Carey, )
    Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Scott Carey, )
     Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Tom Lane, )
      Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Alvaro Herrera, )
       Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  ("Jignesh K. Shah", )
        Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (decibel, )
      Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Scott Carey, )
    Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Tom Lane, )
     Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Scott Carey, )
    Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  ("Jignesh K. Shah", )
 Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  (Simon Riggs, )
  Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4  ("Jignesh K. Shah", )

"Kevin Grittner" <> writes:
> I'm wondering about the testing methodology.

Me too.  This test case seems much too far away from real world use
to justify diddling low-level locking behavior; especially a change
that is obviously likely to have very negative effects in other
scenarios.  In particular, I think it would lead to complete starvation
of would-be exclusive lockers in the face of competition from a steady
stream of shared lockers.  AFAIR the existing behavior was designed
to reduce the odds of that, not for any other purpose.

            regards, tom lane


pgsql-performance by date:

From: "Jignesh K. Shah"
Date:
Subject: Re: Proposal of tunable fix for scalability of 8.4
From: Guillaume Smet
Date:
Subject: Re: Full statement logging problematic on larger machines?