Re: pg_dumpall forces plain text format - Mailing list pgsql-bugs

From Andrew Kohlsmith
Subject Re: pg_dumpall forces plain text format
Date
Msg-id 200207110943.20717@-mixdown.ca
Whole thread Raw
In response to Re: pg_dumpall forces plain text format  (Tom Lane <tgl@sss.pgh.pa.us>)
Responses Re: pg_dumpall forces plain text format
List pgsql-bugs
> > Is there a particular reason why plain text is forced?
> Because pg_dumpall is producing a script file.
> This is obviously not optimal, but it's not very clear how to do better.

Agreed.  :-)

I notice that pg_dumpall just uses a query to grab a list of databases and
some information about them and then cycles through them and runs pg_dump for
each one to dump it.  I could easily do this myself but that would mean that
both pg_dumpall and whatever method I come up with do not guarantee
referential integrity across databases (I'm specifically thinking about
foreign keys).

Now IIRC, Postgres doesn't allow foreign keys across databases so this point
is moot at this time.  Is there a way to start a transaction at the start of
the dump and hold it throughout successive connections, finally releasing it
at the end?  Or is that on the TODO for whenever foreign keys can be across
databases?

Regards,
Andrew

pgsql-bugs by date:

Previous
From: Hugo Jonker
Date:
Subject: Re: Bug #711: Automatic created indexes can in some cases not be referenced to
Next
From: Andrew Kohlsmith
Date:
Subject: Re: pg_dumpall forces plain text format