Postgres Pro
Downloads
Home   >   mailing lists

Thread: insufficient privilege with pg_read_all_stats granted

insufficient privilege with pg_read_all_stats granted

From
Costa Alexoglou
Date:
Hey folks,

I run PostgreSQL v15.8 (docker official image), and there is an issue when reading pg_stat_staments table with a result of query most of the times having `<insufficient privilege>` value.

I have created the user that I use to fetch the data with the following way:
```
CREATE USER abcd WITH NOSUPERUSER NOCREATEROLE NOINHERIT LOGIN;

GRANT pg_read_all_stats, pg_stat_scan_tables, pg_read_all_settings to abcd;

GRANT pg_monitor to abcd;
```

I explicitly gave `pg_read_all_stats` and also called `pg_monitor` just to be on the safe side, but stil I get the insufficient privilege error.

```
SELECT
   r.rolname AS member,
   m.rolname AS role
FROM
   pg_auth_members am
JOIN
   pg_roles r ON r.oid = am.member
JOIN
   pg_roles m ON m.oid = am.roleid
WHERE
   m.rolname = 'pg_read_all_stats'
   AND r.rolname = 'abcd';

 member |       role
--------+-------------------
 abcd   | pg_read_all_stats
(1 row)
```

I also tried with PostgreSQL v14.13, and this was not the case, it was working fine as expected.
Then I tried v16.4 and v17beta3, and I faced the <insufficient privilege> issue, so I guess something changed v15 onwards?

Re: insufficient privilege with pg_read_all_stats granted

From
Pavel Luzanov
Date:
On 20.08.2024 23:50, Costa Alexoglou wrote:
I run PostgreSQL v15.8 (docker official image), and there is an issue when reading pg_stat_staments table with a result of query most of the times having `<insufficient privilege>` value.

I have created the user that I use to fetch the data with the following way:
```
CREATE USER abcd WITH NOSUPERUSER NOCREATEROLE NOINHERIT LOGIN;

GRANT pg_read_all_stats, pg_stat_scan_tables, pg_read_all_settings to abcd;
I think the problem is in the NOINHERIT attribute for the abcd role.
abcd does not inherit the privileges gained from being included in other roles.

In v15, to see the text of SQL commands in pg_stat_statements, you can either explicitly
switch from abcd role to the pg_read_all_stats role (SET ROLE pg_read_all_stats)
or set the INHERIT attribute for abcd role (alter role abcd inherit).

In v16, you can explicitly specify how to get privileges in the GRANT command:

grant pg_read_all_stats to abcd with inherit true, set false;


I also tried with PostgreSQL v14.13, and this was not the case, it was working fine as expected.
Then I tried v16.4 and v17beta3, and I faced the <insufficient privilege> issue, so I guess something changed v15 onwards?
But I don't understand why it worked in v14.
Probably something has changed, but I couldn't quickly find what exactly.
-- 
Pavel Luzanov
Postgres Professional: https://postgrespro.com

Re: insufficient privilege with pg_read_all_stats granted

From
Pavel Luzanov
Date:
On 21.08.2024 10:50, Pavel Luzanov wrote:
But I don't understand why it worked in v14.
Probably something has changed, but I couldn't quickly find what exactly.
I found it.
https://github.com/postgres/postgres/commit/6198420a
-- 
Pavel Luzanov
Postgres Professional: https://postgrespro.com

Re: insufficient privilege with pg_read_all_stats granted

From
Costa Alexoglou
Date:
> I think the problem is in the NOINHERIT attribute for the abcd role.

Indeed that is the issue, thanks for helping find this out