Thread: How to best migrate this nested join ?

How to best migrate this nested join ?

From
Gary M
Date:
Hi,

I have this nested join taken from some old  sybase code.

SELECT
     TBL1.ID AS ID1,
     TBL4.ID AS ID2,
     TBL5.ID AS ID3,
     TBL6.ID AS ID4
FROM TBL1, TBL2, TBL3, TBL4, TBL5, TBL6, TBL7 WHERE TBL1.AA *= TBL2.AA and TBL1.AA = TBL3.AA and TBL4.AB = TBL3.CD and AB = 'TBL4' /* not sure where AB is coming from */ and TBL4.AB = TBL7.AB and TBL7.ZZ = 0 and TBL4.AB *= TBL6.AB and TBL4.AB *= TBL5.AB ;
How should these joins be nested using pg-sql ? 

-g

Re: How to best migrate this nested join ?

From
"David G. Johnston"
Date:
On Thu, Mar 1, 2018 at 2:16 PM, Gary M <garym@oedata.com> wrote:
Hi,

I have this nested join taken from some old  sybase code.

SELECT
     TBL1.ID AS ID1,
     TBL4.ID AS ID2,
     TBL5.ID AS ID3,
     TBL6.ID AS ID4
FROM TBL1, TBL2, TBL3, TBL4, TBL5, TBL6, TBL7 WHERE TBL1.AA *= TBL2.AA and TBL1.AA = TBL3.AA and TBL4.AB = TBL3.CD and AB = 'TBL4' /* not sure where AB is coming from */ and TBL4.AB = TBL7.AB and TBL7.ZZ = 0 and TBL4.AB *= TBL6.AB and TBL4.AB *= TBL5.AB ;
How should these joins be nested using pg-sql ? 


​*= means left join, I presume​

​(not tested)​

FROM TBL1
JOIN TBL3 ON (TBL1.AA = TBL3.AA)
JOIN TBL4 ON (TBL3.CD = TBL4.AB)
JOIN TBL7 ON (TBL4.AB = TBL7.AB)
LEFT JOIN TBL2 ON (TBL1.AA = TBL2.AA)
LEFT JOIN TBL5 ON (TBL4.AB = TBL5.AB)
LEFT JOIN TBL6 ON (TBL4.AB = TBL6.AB)
​WHERE TBL4.AB = 'TBL4'
AND TBL7.ZZ = 0

I suggest the following related reading.


David J.

Re: How to best migrate this nested join ?

From
Gary M
Date:
Thanks David,

I'm just coming up to speed on pg after 10-15 years away.

On Thu, Mar 1, 2018 at 2:31 PM, David G. Johnston <david.g.johnston@gmail.com> wrote:
On Thu, Mar 1, 2018 at 2:16 PM, Gary M <garym@oedata.com> wrote:
Hi,

I have this nested join taken from some old  sybase code.

SELECT
     TBL1.ID AS ID1,
     TBL4.ID AS ID2,
     TBL5.ID AS ID3,
     TBL6.ID AS ID4
FROM TBL1, TBL2, TBL3, TBL4, TBL5, TBL6, TBL7 WHERE TBL1.AA *= TBL2.AA and TBL1.AA = TBL3.AA and TBL4.AB = TBL3.CD and AB = 'TBL4' /* not sure where AB is coming from */ and TBL4.AB = TBL7.AB and TBL7.ZZ = 0 and TBL4.AB *= TBL6.AB and TBL4.AB *= TBL5.AB ;
How should these joins be nested using pg-sql ? 


​*= means left join, I presume​

​(not tested)​

FROM TBL1
JOIN TBL3 ON (TBL1.AA = TBL3.AA)
JOIN TBL4 ON (TBL3.CD = TBL4.AB)
JOIN TBL7 ON (TBL4.AB = TBL7.AB)
LEFT JOIN TBL2 ON (TBL1.AA = TBL2.AA)
LEFT JOIN TBL5 ON (TBL4.AB = TBL5.AB)
LEFT JOIN TBL6 ON (TBL4.AB = TBL6.AB)
​WHERE TBL4.AB = 'TBL4'
AND TBL7.ZZ = 0

I suggest the following related reading.


David J.