Thread: sql error creating function

sql error creating function

From
TJ O'Donnell
Date:
When I psql -f f.sql
I get the following error:
psql:f.sql:10: ERROR:  relation "fragset" does not exist
CONTEXT:  SQL function "fragments"
> cat f.sql
Create Or Replace Function fragments(character varying) Returns setof character varying
As $$

Create Temporary Table fragset (smiles character varying);
Insert into fragset Values ('COCNC');
Insert into fragset Values ('COCNCc1ccccc1');
Select smiles from fragset;

$$ Language SQL;

But, if I paste into a running psql the commands:

Create Temporary Table fragset (smiles character varying);
Insert into fragset Values ('COCNC');
Insert into fragset Values ('COCNCc1ccccc1');
Select smiles from fragset;

it works fine.

What is wrong in the function definition?
I'm using 8.1.3

Thanks,
TJ O'Donnell


Re: sql error creating function

From
Christopher Browne
Date:
Quoth tjo@acm.org ("TJ O'Donnell"):
> When I psql -f f.sql
> I get the following error:
> psql:f.sql:10: ERROR:  relation "fragset" does not exist
> CONTEXT:  SQL function "fragments"
>
>> cat f.sql
> Create Or Replace Function fragments(character varying)
>  Returns setof character varying
> As $$
>
> Create Temporary Table fragset (smiles character varying);
> Insert into fragset Values ('COCNC');
> Insert into fragset Values ('COCNCc1ccccc1');
> Select smiles from fragset;
>
> $$ Language SQL;
>
> But, if I paste into a running psql the commands:
>
> Create Temporary Table fragset (smiles character varying);
> Insert into fragset Values ('COCNC');
> Insert into fragset Values ('COCNCc1ccccc1');
> Select smiles from fragset;
>
> it works fine.
>
> What is wrong in the function definition?
> I'm using 8.1.3

Presumably it's that the query plan is evaluated based on the state of
the database *before* the function runs, at which point table
'fragset' does not exist.  Creation of the temp table will work fine,
but the references to it don't, because when the query (to run the
whole thing) is planned, the table doesn't exist.

What you need to do is to generate the various queries on fragset as
dynamic queries, invoked via "execute."  That will cause the planner
to run on each statement...
-- 
output = reverse("moc.liamg" "@" "enworbbc")
http://linuxdatabases.info/info/wp.html
"We believe Windows 95 is a walking antitrust violation"
-- Bryan Sparks