Thread: 9.2 CF2: 20 days in
Hackers, Commitfest 2 continues to progress ... slowly. At this point, we have no hope of wrapping it up early; my best hope is to at least finish on time. Statistics: * 1/2 of patches are still pending development: 12 waiting on author, and 18 waiting for review. In addition, 7 patches are waiting for a committer. * 28 patches have been committed or returned, about 45%. In addition to nudging the reviewers who have not delivered (going out tommorrow) I really need reviewers for a few patches which have none. These are all difficult, complex patches to review: 1) Collect frequency statistics and selectivity estimation for arrays 2) Kaigai's remaining security patches 3) Robert's VXID and table locks patches. If you are a seasoned PostgreSQL hacker and available to review any of the above, please volunteer now. Also, if you are a patch author or reviewer, please check to see that the status of your patch is updated in the commitfest application. I may have missed a few messages due to the US holiday. -- Josh Berkus PostgreSQL Experts Inc. http://pgexperts.com
On Thu, Jul 7, 2011 at 12:02 AM, Josh Berkus <josh@agliodbs.com> wrote: > * 1/2 of patches are still pending development: 12 waiting on author, > and 18 waiting for review. In addition, 7 patches are waiting for a > committer. We need to start marking the patches that are "Waiting on Author" as "Returned with Feedback", ideally after checking that the status in the CF application is in fact up to date. With a week left in the CommitFest at this point, anything that has been reviewed and still has issues is pretty much going to have to wait for the next round. We need to focus on (a) reviewing the patches that haven't been reviewed yet and (b) getting the stuff that is basically in good shape committed. Otherwise, we're still going to be doing this CommitFest in September. I have been attempting to keep somewhat on top of the stuff that has become Ready for Committer, but there is too much of it for me to handle by myself. -- Robert Haas EnterpriseDB: http://www.enterprisedb.com The Enterprise PostgreSQL Company
Robert, > We need to start marking the patches that are "Waiting on Author" as > "Returned with Feedback", ideally after checking that the status in > the CF application is in fact up to date. With a week left in the > CommitFest at this point, anything that has been reviewed and still > has issues is pretty much going to have to wait for the next round. > We need to focus on (a) reviewing the patches that haven't been > reviewed yet and (b) getting the stuff that is basically in good > shape > committed. Otherwise, we're still going to be doing this CommitFest > in September Sure, I only want to do that for ones which have been waiting on author for more than a couple days though. Working on that. > I have been attempting to keep somewhat on top of the stuff that has > become Ready for Committer, but there is too much of it for me to > handle by myself. Yeah, given that we're still in beta, I expected committing to be a problem. Not a surprise. --Josh
Joshua Berkus <josh@agliodbs.com> writes:
>> I have been attempting to keep somewhat on top of the stuff that has
>> become Ready for Committer, but there is too much of it for me to
>> handle by myself.
> Yeah, given that we're still in beta, I expected committing to be a problem. Not a surprise.
Between beta and vacation, I've not been able to provide any help in
this CF. I'm still catching up from vacation but should be able to
provide some help next week.
regards, tom lane
On Thu, Jul 7, 2011 at 1:35 PM, Tom Lane <tgl@sss.pgh.pa.us> wrote: > Joshua Berkus <josh@agliodbs.com> writes: >>> I have been attempting to keep somewhat on top of the stuff that has >>> become Ready for Committer, but there is too much of it for me to >>> handle by myself. > >> Yeah, given that we're still in beta, I expected committing to be a problem. Not a surprise. > > Between beta and vacation, I've not been able to provide any help in > this CF. I'm still catching up from vacation but should be able to > provide some help next week. That would be great, especially because I am leaving for a week's vacation on Saturday, and so my availability to help with the final push is going to be limited. -- Robert Haas EnterpriseDB: http://www.enterprisedb.com The Enterprise PostgreSQL Company