Thread: BUG #2123: join between stored procedures

The following bug has been logged online:

Bug reference:      2123
Logged by:          Konstantin S. Zhinko [tIT]
Email address:      k.zhinko@grape.ru
PostgreSQL version: 8.1.0
Operating system:   CentOS 3.5
Description:        join between stored procedures
Details:

Hi all!

I have a very big problem...

Here the code:

/*SQL START*/

CREATE TABLE "public"."test_data" (
  "id" INTEGER NOT NULL,
  "type" INTEGER NOT NULL,
  "short_text" VARCHAR(255),
  CONSTRAINT "test_data_pkey" PRIMARY KEY("id")
) WITH OIDS;

CREATE TYPE "public"."ret_id" AS (
  "id" INTEGER
);

CREATE TYPE "public"."test" AS (
  "id" INTEGER,
  "type" INTEGER,
  "info" VARCHAR(255)
);

CREATE OR REPLACE FUNCTION "public"."get_obj_list" () RETURNS SETOF
"public"."ret_id" AS
$body$
declare
       ret ret_id;
begin

     for ret in select test_data.id from test_data
     loop

     return next ret;

     end loop;

end;
$body$
LANGUAGE 'plpgsql' VOLATILE CALLED ON NULL INPUT SECURITY INVOKER;

CREATE OR REPLACE FUNCTION "public"."get_obj" (id integer) RETURNS
"public"."test" AS
$body$
declare
       ret test;
       in_id alias for $1;

begin

     select * from test_data a into ret where a.id=in_id;
     return ret;

end;
$body$
LANGUAGE 'plpgsql' VOLATILE CALLED ON NULL INPUT SECURITY INVOKER;

/*SQL END*/

It is ok, but when I try to join these procedures, server responses error

/*SQL START*/
SELECT b.*
FROM get_obj_list a
  LEFT JOIN get_obj(a.id) b ON 1=1
/*SQL END*/

Error: relation "a" does not exists.

Why it's so?

"Konstantin S. Zhinko [tIT]" <k.zhinko@grape.ru> writes:
> SELECT b.*
> FROM get_obj_list a
>   LEFT JOIN get_obj(a.id) b ON 1=1
> Error: relation "a" does not exists.

This is not a bug.  You cannot make use of values from one <table
reference> inside the definition of another <table reference>.
So the reference "a.id" is taken to be to a real table named "a",
not to the "a" alias elsewhere in the query.

You could do something like

    SELECT (get_obj(id)).* FROM get_obj_list();

instead.

            regards, tom lane