Optimizing a query - Mailing list pgsql-performance

From James Cloos
Subject Optimizing a query
Date
Msg-id m31wn3lji6.fsf@lugabout.jhcloos.org
Whole thread Raw
Responses Re: Optimizing a query
Re: Optimizing a query
List pgsql-performance
I've currently got this table:

,----
| n=# \d nanpa
|          Table "public.nanpa"
|    Column   |     Type     | Modifiers
| ------------+--------------+-----------
|  state      | character(2) |
|  npa        | character(3) | not null
|  nxx        | character(3) | not null
|  ocn        | character(4) |
|  company    | text         |
|  ratecenter | text         |
|  switch     | text         |
|  effective  | date         |
|  use        | character(2) | not null
|  assign     | date         |
|  ig         | character(1) |
| Indexes:
|     "nanpa_pkey" PRIMARY KEY, btree (npa, nxx) CLUSTER
`----

and was doing queries of the form:

,----
| select * from nanpa where npa=775 and nxx=413;
`----

where were quite slow.  Explain showed that it was doing sequential
scans even though the primary key contained the two term I was
selecting on.

Today, looking at it again in prep to this post, I noticed that the
numbers were being converted to ::text, and a quick test showed that
queries of the form:

,----
| select * from nanpa where npa=775::bpchar and nxx=413::bpchar;
`----

used the index.

I specified char(3) when I created the table simple because npa and
nxx are defined as three-character strings.  Tagging the queies is
a pain, especially as I often do queries of that form in psql(1).

(Incidently, there are multiple similar tables, also keyed on
(npa,nxx), which show the same problem.  The nanpa table above is
just a good example.)

Should I convert the columns to text?  Or create an additional index
that expects ::text args?  (If so, how?)

Or is there some other way to ensure the indices get used w/o having
to tag data in the queries?

Thanks,

-JimC
--
James Cloos <cloos@jhcloos.com>         OpenPGP: 1024D/ED7DAEA6

pgsql-performance by date:

Previous
From: Tom Lane
Date:
Subject: Re: strange query behavior
Next
From: "Tomeh, Husam"
Date:
Subject: Re: Optimizing a query