Re: Problems with ordering (can't force query planner to use an index) - Mailing list pgsql-performance

But it's already attached in the first mail or am I missing something?

If you don't see it, check this: http://pastebin.com/d71b996d0

Sebastjan



On Tue, Mar 3, 2009 at 6:12 PM, Robert Haas <robertmhaas@gmail.com> wrote:
> On Tue, Mar 3, 2009 at 12:05 PM, Sebastjan Trepca <trepca@gmail.com> wrote:
>> Hey,
>>
>> I have a table that links content together and it currently holds
>> about 17 mio records. Typical query is a join with a content table and
>> link table:
>>
>> noovo-new=# explain analyze SELECT "core_accessor"."id",
>> "core_accessor"."content_type_id",
>> "core_accessor"."object_id", "core_accessor"."ordering",
>> "core_accessor"."label", "core_accessor"."date_posted",
>> "core_accessor"."publish_state", "core_accessor"."nooximity_old",
>> "core_accessor"."rising", "core_accessor"."nooximity",
>> "core_accessor"."nooximity_old_date_posted",
>> "core_accessor"."nooximity_date_posted", "core_accessor"."user_id",
>> "core_accessor"."slot_id", "core_accessor"."slot_type_id",
>> "core_accessor"."role", "core_base"."object_id",
>> "core_base"."content_type_id", "core_base"."abstract",
>> "core_base"."abstract_title", "core_base"."image",
>>  "core_base"."date_posted", "core_base"."date_modified",
>> "core_base"."date_expires", "core_base"."publish_state",
>>  "core_base"."location", "core_base"."location_x",
>> "core_base"."location_y", "core_base"."raw", "core_base"."author_id",
>>  "core_base"."excerpt", "core_base"."state_id",
>> "core_base"."country_id", "core_base"."language",
>> "core_base"."_identifier",
>>  "core_base"."slot_url", "core_base"."source_id",
>> "core_base"."source_content_type_id", "core_base"."source_type",
>>  "core_base"."source_value", "core_base"."source_title",
>> "core_base"."direct_to_source", "core_base"."comment_count",
>>  "core_base"."public" FROM "core_accessor" INNER JOIN core_base AS
>> core_base ON core_base.content_type_id =
>>  core_accessor.content_type_id AND core_base.object_id =
>> core_accessor.object_id WHERE (("core_accessor"."slot_type_id" = 119
>>  AND "core_accessor"."slot_id" = 472 AND "core_accessor"."label" = E''
>> AND "core_accessor"."publish_state" >= 60 AND
>>  "core_accessor"."role" IN (0) AND "core_accessor"."user_id" = 0))
>> order by core_accessor.date_posted, core_accessor.nooximity LIMIT 5
>> ;
>>
>>      QUERY PLAN
>>
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
>>  Limit  (cost=31930.65..31930.66 rows=5 width=860) (actual
>> time=711.924..711.927 rows=5 loops=1)
>>   ->  Sort  (cost=31930.65..31937.80 rows=2861 width=860) (actual
>> time=711.923..711.923 rows=5 loops=1)
>>         Sort Key: core_accessor.date_posted, core_accessor.nooximity
>>         Sort Method:  top-N heapsort  Memory: 31kB
>>         ->  Nested Loop  (cost=0.00..31883.13 rows=2861 width=860)
>> (actual time=0.089..543.497 rows=68505 loops=1)
>>               ->  Index Scan using core_accessor_fresh_idx on
>> core_accessor  (cost=0.00..5460.07 rows=2970 width=92) (actual
>> time=0.068..54.921 rows=69312 loops=1)
>>                     Index Cond: ((slot_id = 472) AND (slot_type_id =
>> 119) AND (label = ''::text) AND (user_id = 0) AND (role = 0) AND
>> (publish_state >= 60))
>>               ->  Index Scan using core_base_pkey on core_base
>> (cost=0.00..8.88 rows=1 width=768) (actual time=0.004..0.005 rows=1
>> loops=69312)
>>                     Index Cond: ((core_base.object_id =
>> core_accessor.object_id) AND (core_base.content_type_id =
>> core_accessor.content_type_id))
>>  Total runtime: 712.031 ms
>> (10 rows)
>>
>> noovo-new=# select * from pg_stat_user_tables where relname='core_accessor';
>>  relid | schemaname |    relname    | seq_scan | seq_tup_read |
>> idx_scan | idx_tup_fetch | n_tup_ins | n_tup_upd | n_tup_del |
>> n_tup_hot_upd | n_live_tup | n_dead_tup |          last_vacuum
>>  | last_autovacuum |         last_analyze          | last_autoanalyze
>>
-------+------------+---------------+----------+--------------+----------+---------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+---------------+------------+------------+-------------------------------+-----------------+-------------------------------+------------------
>>  51159 | public     | core_accessor |       58 |    749773516 |
>> 13785608 |     149165183 |      9566 |       548 |       347 |
>>  206 |   17144303 |        251 | 2009-03-03 07:02:19.733778-06 |
>>           | 2009-03-03 06:17:47.784268-06 |
>> (1 row)
>>
>> noovo-new=# \d+ core_accessor;
>>                                                  Table "public.core_accessor"
>>          Column           |           Type           |
>>         Modifiers                          | Description
>>
---------------------------+--------------------------+------------------------------------------------------------+-------------
>>  id                        | bigint                   | not null
>> default nextval('core_accessor_id_seq'::regclass) |
>>  flavor                    | character varying(32)    |
>>                                            |
>>  content_type_id           | integer                  | not null
>>                                            |
>>  object_id                 | integer                  | not null
>>                                            |
>>  publish_state             | smallint                 | not null
>>                                            |
>>  date_posted               | timestamp with time zone | not null
>>                                            |
>>  user_id                   | integer                  |
>>                                            |
>>  slot_id                   | integer                  |
>>                                            |
>>  slot_type_id              | integer                  |
>>                                            |
>>  role                      | smallint                 |
>>                                            |
>>  ordering                  | integer                  |
>>                                            |
>>  author_id                 | integer                  |
>>                                            |
>>  nooximity_old             | double precision         | default 0.0
>>                                            |
>>  rising                    | double precision         | default 0.0
>>                                            |
>>  label                     | text                     |
>>                                            |
>>  nooximity                 | double precision         | not null
>> default 1.0                                       |
>>  nooximity_old_date_posted | timestamp with time zone |
>>                                            |
>>  nooximity_date_posted     | timestamp with time zone |
>>                                            |
>> Indexes:
>>    "portal_metainfo_pkey" PRIMARY KEY, btree (id)
>>    "portal_metainfo_unique_constr" UNIQUE, btree (content_type_id,
>> object_id, user_id, slot_id, slot_type_id, role, label) CLUSTER
>>    "core_accessor_date_idx" btree (date_posted, nooximity)
>>    "core_accessor_dated_idx" btree (slot_id, slot_type_id, label,
>> user_id, role, publish_state, date_posted, nooximity)
>>    "core_accessor_fresh_idx" btree (slot_id, slot_type_id, label,
>> user_id, role, publish_state)
>>    "core_accessor_popularity_idx" btree (nooximity, date_posted)
>> Check constraints:
>>    "portal_metainfo_object_id_check" CHECK (object_id >= 0)
>>    "portal_metainfo_owner_id_check" CHECK (slot_id >= 0)
>> Foreign-key constraints:
>>    "portal_metainfo_accessor_id_fkey" FOREIGN KEY (user_id)
>> REFERENCES auth_user(id) DEFERRABLE INITIALLY DEFERRED
>>    "portal_metainfo_content_type_id_fkey" FOREIGN KEY
>> (content_type_id) REFERENCES django_content_type(id) DEFERRABLE
>> INITIALLY DEFERRED
>>    "portal_metainfo_owner_type_id_fkey" FOREIGN KEY (slot_type_id)
>> REFERENCES django_content_type(id) DEFERRABLE INITIALLY DEFERRED
>> Has OIDs: no
>>
>>
>>
>> As far as I understand the explain, it fetches 68505 rows, matches
>> them with core_base and then tries to sort them? AFAIK it would
>> probably be much more effective to just find the records in accessor
>> via core_accessor_dated_idx and then lookup the core_base table? But
>> for some reason it doesn't want to?
>>
>> I ran analyze, vacuum and reindex but nothing helped. Queries just eat
>> all the I/O and block. There is a huge difference between cached and
>> non-cached queries, like 50.000 to 50 ms.
>>
>> Help! :)
>
> Please send the output of EXPLAIN ANALYZE for this query.
>
> ...Robert
>