Re: set difference - Mailing list pgsql-sql

From Domoszlai László
Subject Re: set difference
Date
Msg-id D6CD29CE4DF67F47A11FB6CF5EBE15D1375753@gedeon.finit.local
Whole thread Raw
In response to set difference  (Domoszlai László <dlacko@finit.hu>)
Responses Re: set difference
List pgsql-sql
Tom Lane wrote:
> > I would like to make symmetrical(set) difference in a query.
> > But the simpliest way I could find is
>
> > select id from a
> > except
> > select id from b
> > union
> > select id from b
> > except
> > select id from a
>
> > Is there any better solution for this problem?
>
> One thing you should definitely do is change "union" to "union all".
> "union" implies a pass of duplicate removal, which shouldn't be
> necessary here (unless a or b individually contain duplicates and
> you want to get rid of those too).
>
> Another thing to try is
>     (a union b) except (a intersect b)
> (Again, you might be able to say union all instead of union.)
> Not sure which will be faster.

It's likely faster but my problem is I have to run queries twice. I've looked at
setOp executor and it seems symmetrical differencial can run as time as an EXCEPT.
I would write it, because it speeds up my query very much, but I don't know if it is worth. So, do you think a
DIFFERENCEor EXCEPT SYMMETRIC clause will be reasonable  
feauture for postgresql?

Laca


pgsql-sql by date:

Previous
From: "alexandre :: aldeia digital"
Date:
Subject: pg_atoi() error
Next
From: Tom Lane
Date:
Subject: Re: set difference