Clean way to insert records if they don't exist, update if they do - Mailing list pgsql-general

From Mike Christensen
Subject Clean way to insert records if they don't exist, update if they do
Date
Msg-id CABs1bs20R_vOL5TfyO-mw-aD8SE=LhBWbnX2Rzdpd8UyAJax-g@mail.gmail.com
Whole thread Raw
Responses Re: Clean way to insert records if they don't exist, update if they do  (Diego Augusto Molina <diegoaugustomolina@gmail.com>)
List pgsql-general
Here's my situation.  I have a table with a bunch of URLs and crawl
dates associated with them.  When my program processes a URL, I want
to INSERT a new row with a crawl date.  If the URL already exists, I
want to update the crawl date to the current datetime.  With MS SQL or
Oracle I'd probably use a MERGE command for this.  With mySQL I'd
probably use the ON DUPLICATE KEY UPDATE syntax.

I could do multiple queries in my program, which may or may not be
thread safe.  I could write a SQL function which has various IF...ELSE
logic.  However, for the sake of trying out Postgres features I've
never used before, I'm thinking about creating an INSERT rule -
something like this:

CREATE RULE Pages_Upsert AS ON INSERT TO Pages
   WHERE EXISTS (SELECT 1 from Pages P where NEW.Url = P.Url)
   DO INSTEAD
      UPDATE Pages SET LastCrawled = NOW(), Html = NEW.Html WHERE Url = NEW.Url;

This seems to actually work great.  It probably loses some points on
the "code readability" standpoint, as someone looking at my code for
the first time would have to magically know about this rule, but I
guess that could be solved with good code commenting and
documentation.

Are there any other drawbacks to this idea, or maybe a "your idea
sucks, you should do it /this/ way instead" comment?  I'm on PG 9.0 if
that matters.  BTW, add my name to the long list of people who would
love to see UPSERT and/or MERGE commands in the next version of PG.

Mike

pgsql-general by date:

Previous
From: Scott Marlowe
Date:
Subject: Re: Am I best off keeping large chunks of text in a separate table?
Next
From: "Edson Carlos Ericksson Richter"
Date:
Subject: Foreign tables using postgresql_fdw or odbc_fdw