On Sat, Jan 7, 2017 at 4:15 AM, Daniel Verite <daniel@manitou-mail.org> wrote:
> The defaults comes from these definitions, in include/pg_config_manual.h
>
> /*
> * Set the upper and lower bounds of sequence values.
> */
> #define SEQ_MAXVALUE PG_INT64_MAX
> #define SEQ_MINVALUE (-SEQ_MAXVALUE)
>
> with no comment as to why SEQ_MINVALUE is not PG_INT64_MIN.
Bruce likely does not remember 8000fdd4 from 2003. I stopped tracking there.
> When using other types than bigint, Peter's patch fixes the inconsistency
> but also makes it worse by ISTM applying the rule that the lowest value
> is forbidden for int2 and int4 in addition to int8.
I think that mapping a sequence to a data type gives a good argument
to have the range mapping with the data type involved. That's less
surprise for the users, and less code to think about range boundaries.
Also, restoring from a dump sequences won't result in an error for
sequence definitions using PG_INT**_MIN as minimum value.
--
Michael
