Re: Storage Location / Tablespaces (try 3) - Mailing list pgsql-hackers

From Zeugswetter Andreas SB SD
Subject Re: Storage Location / Tablespaces (try 3)
Date
Msg-id 46C15C39FEB2C44BA555E356FBCD6FA4961D67@m0114.s-mxs.net
Whole thread Raw
In response to Storage Location / Tablespaces (try 3)  ("Jim Buttafuoco" <jim@buttafuoco.net>)
Responses Re: Storage Location / Tablespaces (try 3)  ("Jim Buttafuoco" <jim@buttafuoco.net>)
List pgsql-hackers
> (If people like TABLESPACE instead of LOCATION then
> s/LOCATION/TABLESPACE/g
> below)

I like "tablespace" :-)

> This patch would add the following NEW commands
> ----------------------------------------------------
>     CREATE LOCATION name PATH 'dbpath';
>     DROP   LOCATION name;

> The following command syntax would be modified
> ------------------------------------------------------
> CREATE DATABASE WITH DATA_LOCATION=XXX INDEX_LOCATION=YYY
> TEMP_LOCATION=ZZZ
> CREATE TABLE aaa (...) WITH LOCATION=XXX;
> CREATE TABLE bbb (c1 text primary key location CCC) WITH LOCATION=XXX;
> CREATE TABLE ccc (c2 text unique location CCC) WITH LOCATION=XXX;
> CREATE INDEX XXX on SAMPLE (C2) WITH LOCATION BBB;

Sounds great, but shouldn't we use syntax that is already around,
like Oracle's or DB2's or ...

> The symbolic links will enable the rest of the software to be location
> independent.

I see, that this is the least intrusive way, but I am not sure this is the
best way to do it. It would probably be better to pass the Tablespace oid
around (or look it up).

That would also leave the door open for other "Tablespace types" (currently
"Filesystem directory" an OS managed tablespace :-).

Andreas


pgsql-hackers by date:

Previous
From: Karel Zak
Date:
Subject: Re: date formatting and tab-complete patch
Next
From:
Date:
Subject: Re: Postgresql backend to perform vacuum automatically