Oracle VP on MySQL - Mailing list pgsql-advocacy

From Ned Lilly
Subject Oracle VP on MySQL
Date
Msg-id 407EBB63.5080806@nedscape.com
Whole thread Raw
List pgsql-advocacy
Interesting read at http://www.eweek.com/article2/0,1759,1567752,00.asp

It's an interview with the Oracle VP product strategy.  Interestingly, in five pages, there's no mention of PostgreSQL.
I've got to say that I agree with some of his analysis of MySQL, however, particularly these four paragraphs: 

"MySQL production releases have typically been two years apart, and the time from alpha [first release] to production
isabout 1.5 years. They released Version 5.0 in alpha status in December 2003, so a reasonable expectation for
productionrelease of Version 5.0 is mid-2005. 

It should be noted that MySQL Version 5.0 introduced stored procedures but not triggers or views, both of which are
essentialfor significant enterprise applications. It appears unlikely that MySQL could introduce these critical
featuresmuch before mid-2007. A whole wide range of additional capabilities including but not limited to XML and
analytic—i.e.business-intelligence—features do not appear to be on the MySQL radar. 

Furthermore, the low level of resources available to MySQL to fund development and the very small size of their
developmentteam raise questions about the viability of the MySQL business model and technology development path going
forward. 

It is unlikely that MySQL can rapidly accelerate development of their core product while acquiring and integrating
disparatedatabase technologies like the SAP DB (now called MaxDB) or MySQL Cluster. Indeed, this sort of 'engineering
byacquisition' is a distraction and fragments their development efforts." 



pgsql-advocacy by date:

Previous
From: Satoshi Nagayasu
Date:
Subject: Re: PostgreSQL CD based on Morphix
Next
From: Chris Browne
Date:
Subject: Re: Oracle VP on MySQL