Error in from_char() for field 'D'? - Mailing list pgsql-hackers

From Brendan Jurd
Subject Error in from_char() for field 'D'?
Date
Msg-id 37ed240d0611081208n6926ac21r81d04cd78ae0e020@mail.gmail.com
Whole thread Raw
Responses Re: Error in from_char() for field 'D'?  (Tom Lane <tgl@sss.pgh.pa.us>)
List pgsql-hackers
Hey hackers,

I was doing some work in backend/utils/adt/formatting.c, and found the
following:
    case DCH_D:        INVALID_FOR_INTERVAL;        if (is_to_char)        {            sprintf(inout, "%d",
tm->tm_wday+ 1);            if (S_THth(suf))                str_numth(p_inout, inout, S_TH_TYPE(suf));
returnstrlen(p_inout);        }        else        {            sscanf(inout, "%1d", &tmfc->d);            return
strspace_len(inout)+ 1 + SKIP_THth(suf);        }
 

The tm_wday field is internally stored as an integer 0 - 6, with 0
being Sunday.  The 'D' formatting field, as per the documentation,
gives 1 - 7 with 1 being Sunday.  So to convert tm_wday to 'D' in
to_char(), you add one.  This works as expected.

However, in from_char(), the reverse is not true.  Looking at the code
snippet above, the digit is scanned straight into tmfc->d unaltered
(this value is later copied directly to tm->tm_wday circa line 3394).

Unless I'm missing something, when converting to text, 'D' yields 1-7,
but when converting back from text, 'D' expects 0-6.

It's not a major problem, since there's not really a use-case for
specifying dates for conversion with the 'D' field, but this behaviour
appears to be incorrect, or at the very least, incorrectly documented.

The fix should be trivial; subtract one from tmfc->d after the call to sscanf()

Regards,
BJ


pgsql-hackers by date:

Previous
From: Oleg Bartunov
Date:
Subject: Re: string_to_array eats too much memory?
Next
From: Robert Treat
Date:
Subject: Re: 8.2 Beta 3 Now Available for Download / Testing ...