Remove hardcoded hash opclass function signature exceptions - Mailing list pgsql-hackers

From Peter Eisentraut
Subject Remove hardcoded hash opclass function signature exceptions
Date
Msg-id 29c3b746-69e7-482a-b37c-dbbf7e5b009b@eisentraut.org
Whole thread Raw
List pgsql-hackers
hashvalidate(), which validates the signatures of support functions for 
the hash AM, contains several hardcoded exceptions.  For example, 
hash/date_ops support function 1 is hashint4(), which would ordinarily 
fail validation because the function argument is int4, not date.  But 
this works internally because int4 and date are of the same size.  There 
are several more exceptions like this that happen to work and were 
allowed historically but would now fail the function signature validation.

AFAICT, these exceptions were just carried over from before the current 
index AM API and validation functions were added.  The code contains 
comments like "For the moment, fix it by having a list of allowed 
cases.", so it probably wasn't meant as the ideal state.

This patch removes those exceptions by providing new support functions 
that have the proper declared signatures.  They internally share most of 
the C code with the "wrong" functions they replace, so the behavior is 
still the same.

With the exceptions gone, hashvalidate() is now simplified and relies 
fully on check_amproc_signature(), similar to other index AMs.

I'm also fixing one case where a brin opclass used hashvarlena() for 
bytea, even though in that case, there is no function signature 
validation done, so it doesn't matter that much.

Not done here, but maybe hashvarlena() and hashvarlenaextended() should 
be removed from pg_proc.dat, since their use as opclass support 
functions is now dubious.  They could continue to exist in the C code as 
internal support functions.
Attachment

pgsql-hackers by date:

Previous
From: Melih Mutlu
Date:
Subject: Vectored IO in XLogWrite()
Next
From: Alexander Korotkov
Date:
Subject: Re: [HACKERS] make async slave to wait for lsn to be replayed