On 2020-Feb-12, Tom Lane wrote:
> For amusement's sake, attached is a screenshot of what Table 9-33
> looks like in A4 format, with my one-row-per-example patch of
> yesterday plus a few manually-added zero-width spaces to break up
> the examples. This is the first PDF rendering of that table that
> I've seen that I actually like.
I like this. The trick of mkaing the first cell take up two or three
rows makes this much clearer and sensible than what I had obtained.
> I also attached a screenshot of a segment of Table 9-31, to show
> what that layout proposal looks like. It's a little busier, but
> it does have the advantage that it's clearer how to apply that
> format to operator tables. The "returns <type>" notation isn't used
> anywhere in SQL for operators, so I am not in love with the idea of
> writing the operator tables that way.
Yeah, that's a little less obvious. I just noticed that the operators
tables show the operator names but not the input datatypes except in the
examples. Perhaps we could use a layout with a cell labelled
"signature" (namest=col2 nameend=col3) instead of input types + return
types and separate them using → which would look like this:
date + integer → date
> Also worth noting is that in most function tables, and certainly
> in the operator tables, we could make the first column narrower.
> The same table with the first column half as wide as the others
> is depicted in the last screenshot. (For this particular table,
> doing that would require breaking some of the longer function
> names such as transaction_timestamp. Not sure whether that's
> a net win, but we do have the option.)
I like making that column narrower.
> One issue that I've found is that the toolchain has no idea that
> the table rows are in groups, so it's happy to split a table
> across pages with a function's description and/or examples on
> a new page. No idea if there's any way around that. Fortunately
> it's not an issue in HTML, so maybe we don't have to fix it.
My vote goes to postponing a solution to this problem :-)
--
Álvaro Herrera https://www.2ndQuadrant.com/
PostgreSQL Development, 24x7 Support, Remote DBA, Training & Services
