'revoke create on database' doesn't work as expected - Mailing list pgsql-general

From Arnout Engelen
Subject 'revoke create on database' doesn't work as expected
Date
Msg-id 20021221011342.GA15706@mintzer.sci.kun.nl
Whole thread Raw
Responses Re: 'revoke create on database' doesn't work as expected  (Tom Lane <tgl@sss.pgh.pa.us>)
List pgsql-general
Hi,

I'm having a bit of trouble using the 'revoke on database' feature
of postgresql 7.3. I've installed postgresql for the first time 2
days ago, so excuse me if I'm doing something stupid here ;)

Suppose I want to deny the user 'arnouten' the privilege of
creating tables in the database 'leenmarkt'. Logged in as 'postgres',
I so:

leenmarkt=# revoke create on database leenmarkt from public;
REVOKE
leenmarkt=# revoke create on database leenmarkt from arnouten;
REVOKE
leenmarkt=# revoke all on database leenmarkt from arnouten;
REVOKE
leenmarkt=# revoke all on database leenmarkt from public;
REVOKE

Now the datacl-field in pg_database is set to
'{=,postgres=CT,leenmarkt=CT}' for the database 'leenmarkt'.

arnouten is not superuser:

  User name  | User ID |         Attributes
 ------------+---------+----------------------------
  arnouten   |     104 |
  leenmarkt  |     102 |
  postgres   |       1 | superuser, create database
  teamherrie |     103 |

The database is owned by postgres:

         List of databases
      Name    |  Owner   | Encoding
  ------------+----------+-----------
   leenmarkt  | postgres | UNICODE
   teamherrie | postgres | UNICODE
   template0  | postgres | SQL_ASCII
   template1  | postgres | SQL_ASCII
   test       | postgres | SQL_ASCII

but still, when I log in as 'arnouten', I can create tables
in the leenmarkt database... Anyone a clue as to what I might
be doing wrong here?


I appreciate your remarks,

Regards,

--
Arnout Engelen <pgsql@bzzt.net>

  "If it sounds good, it /is/ good."
          -- Duke Ellington

pgsql-general by date:

Previous
From: Tom Lane
Date:
Subject: Re: table schema causes crash
Next
From: Tom Lane
Date:
Subject: Re: 'revoke create on database' doesn't work as expected