Re: BUG #3958: Self-Join Group-By Clause Produces Incorrect Results - Mailing list pgsql-bugs

From Tom Lane
Subject Re: BUG #3958: Self-Join Group-By Clause Produces Incorrect Results
Date
Msg-id 15115.1202917232@sss.pgh.pa.us
Whole thread Raw
In response to Re: BUG #3958: Self-Join Group-By Clause Produces Incorrect Results  ("Heikki Linnakangas" <heikki@enterprisedb.com>)
List pgsql-bugs
"Heikki Linnakangas" <heikki@enterprisedb.com> writes:
> Marcus Torres wrote:
>> I wrote a simple self-join query to sum the transaction count of different
>> types of records in a audit table and the result set for the different sum
>> totals was the same which is incorrect.

> Looks perfectly correct to me.

Me too.  The underlying data before grouping/aggregation is

regression=# select
     A1.AUDIT_DATE, P.CONTENT_POLICY_NAME, A1.TXN_COUNT, A2.TXN_COUNT
FROM T_AUDIT A1,
     T_AUDIT A2,
     T_POLICY P
WHERE P.ID = A1.POLICY_ID
  AND P.ID = A2.POLICY_ID
  AND A1.POLICY_ID = A2.POLICY_ID
  AND A1.AUDIT_DATE = A2.AUDIT_DATE
  AND A1.AUDIT_TYPE_CODE = 'CONTENT_1'
  AND A2.AUDIT_TYPE_CODE = 'CONTENT_2';
 audit_date | content_policy_name | txn_count | txn_count
------------+---------------------+-----------+-----------
 2008-01-01 | TEST POLICY         |         1 |         1
 2008-01-01 | TEST POLICY         |         1 |         1
 2008-01-01 | TEST POLICY         |         1 |         1
 2008-01-01 | TEST POLICY         |         1 |         1
 2008-01-01 | TEST POLICY         |         1 |         1
 2008-01-01 | TEST POLICY         |         1 |         1
 2008-01-01 | TEST POLICY         |         1 |         1
 2008-01-01 | TEST POLICY         |         1 |         1
 2008-01-01 | TEST POLICY         |         1 |         1
 2008-01-01 | TEST POLICY         |         1 |         1
(10 rows)

from which it's clear that given all ones in txn_count, the sums *must*
be the same because they're taken over the same number of rows.

I suspect what the OP needs is two separate queries (perhaps union'ed
together) not a self-join.

            regards, tom lane

pgsql-bugs by date:

Previous
From: Rodriguez Fernando
Date:
Subject: Re: BUG #3959: Huge calculation error
Next
From: Marc Munro
Date:
Subject: psql malloc problem