On Fri, Feb 28, 2025 at 02:13:23PM +0100, Álvaro Herrera wrote:
> On 2025-Feb-28, Michael Paquier wrote:
>> Saying that, I have also done similar tests with your v12 for a couple
>> of hours and this looks stable under installcheck-world. I can see
>> that you've reworked quite a bit the surroundings of InitializedFrom
>> in this one. If you apply that once again at some point, the
>> buildfarm will be judge in the long-term, but I am rather confident by
>> saying that the situation looks better here, at least.
>
> Heh, no amount of testing can prove lack of bugs; but for sure "it looks
> different now, so it must be correct" must be the weakest proof of
> correctness I've heard of!
Err, okay. I did use the word "stable" with tests rather than
"correct", and I implied upthread that I did not check the correctness
nor the internals of the patch. If my words held the meaning you
are implying, well, my apologies for the confusion, I guess. I only
tested the patch and it was stable while I've noticed a few diffs with
the previous version, but I did *not* check its internals at all, nor
do I mean that I endorse its logic. I hope that's clear now.
--
Michael
