RE: [EXTERNAL] Re: BUG #18289: postgresql14-devel-14.10-2PGDG.rhel8.x86_64.rpm Contains invalid cLang option in Makefile.global - Mailing list pgsql-bugs

Good morning Thomas.

These are the versions of clang and llvm that are being installed with the rpm in question:
postgresql.org/pub/repos/yum/14/redhat/rhel-8-x86_64/postgresql14-devel-14.10-2PGDG.rhel8.x86_64.rpm

clang-13.0.0-3.module_el8.6.0+1074+380cef3f.x86_64
clang-devel-13.0.0-3.module_el8.6.0+1074+380cef3f.x86_64 
clang-libs-13.0.0-3.module_el8.6.0+1074+380cef3f.x86_64 
clang-resource-filesystem-13.0.0-3.module_el8.6.0+1074+380cef3f.x86_64 
clang-tools-extra-13.0.0-3.module_el8.6.0+1074+380cef3f.x86_64

llvm-compat-libs-13.0.1-2.module_el8.7.0+1142+5343df54.x86_64
llvm-devel-17.0.2-2.module_el8+738+cd33199b.x86_64
llvm-googletest-17.0.2-2.module_el8+738+cd33199b.x86_64
llvm-libs-17.0.2-2.module_el8+738+cd33199b.x86_64
llvm-static-17.0.2-2.module_el8+738+cd33199b.x86_64
llvm-test-17.0.2-2.module_el8+738+cd33199b.x86_64

Here are the sandbox machines details, please let me know if I can provide any other information:

Linux 4.18.0-372.32.1.el8_6.x86_64 #1 SMP Fri Oct 7 12:35:10 EDT 2022 x86_64 x86_64 x86_64 GNU/Linux

Group: Development Tools
 Description: A basic development environment.
 Mandatory Packages:
   autoconf
   automake
   binutils
   bison
   flex
   gcc
   gcc-c++
   gdb
   glibc-devel
   libtool
   make
   pkgconf
   pkgconf-m4
   pkgconf-pkg-config
   redhat-rpm-config
   rpm-build
   rpm-sign
   strace
 Default Packages:
   asciidoc
   byacc
   ctags
   diffstat
   elfutils-libelf-devel
   git
   intltool
   jna
   ltrace
   patchutils
   perl-Fedora-VSP
   perl-Sys-Syslog
   perl-generators
   pesign
   source-highlight
   systemtap
   valgrind
   valgrind-devel
 Optional Packages:
   cmake
   expect
   rpmdevtools
   rpmlint


compiler-rt.x86_64                            13.0.0-1.module_el8.6.0+1029+6594c364   @appstream
                         
 

gcc.x86_64                                    8.5.0-21.el8                            @baseos
                         
 
gcc-c++.x86_64                                8.5.0-21.el8                            @appstream
                         
 
gcc-gdb-plugin.x86_64                         8.5.0-21.el8                            @appstream
                         
 
gcc-plugin-annobin.x86_64                     8.5.0-21.el8                            @baseos
                         
 
gcc-toolset-13.x86_64                         13.0-2.el8                              @@commandline
                         
 
gcc-toolset-13-annobin-docs.noarch            12.32-2.el8                             @appstream
                         
 
gcc-toolset-13-annobin-plugin-gcc.x86_64      12.32-2.el8                             @appstream
                         
 
gcc-toolset-13-binutils.x86_64                2.40-15.el8                             @appstream
                         
 
gcc-toolset-13-binutils-gold.x86_64           2.40-15.el8                             @appstream
                         
 
gcc-toolset-13-dwz.x86_64                     0.14-0.el8                              @appstream
                         
 
gcc-toolset-13-gcc.x86_64                     13.2.1-6.el8                            @appstream
                         
 
gcc-toolset-13-gcc-c++.x86_64                 13.2.1-6.el8                            @appstream
                         
 
gcc-toolset-13-gcc-gfortran.x86_64            13.2.1-6.el8                            @appstream
                         
 
gcc-toolset-13-gdb.x86_64                     12.1-4.el8                              @appstream
                         
 
gcc-toolset-13-libquadmath-devel.x86_64       13.2.1-6.el8                            @appstream
                         
 
gcc-toolset-13-libstdc++-devel.x86_64         13.2.1-6.el8                            @appstream
                         
 
gcc-toolset-13-runtime.x86_64                 13.0-2.el8                              @appstream
                         
 
libgcc.x86_64                                 8.5.0-21.el8                            @baseos
                         
 

java-1.8.0-openjdk-headless.x86_64            1:1.8.0.362.b08-3.el8                   @appstream
                         
 
javapackages-filesystem.noarch                5.3.0-2.module_el8.0.0+30+832da3a1      @powertools
                         
 
tzdata-java.noarch                            2023c-1.el8                             @appstream
                         
 


Installed Packages
gcc.x86_64                                                                                              8.5.0-21.el8
                                                                                         @baseos
 

Installed Packages
gcc.x86_64
8.5.0-21.el8                                                                           @baseos      
 
gcc-c++.x86_64
8.5.0-21.el8                                                                           @appstream   
 
gcc-gdb-plugin.x86_64
8.5.0-21.el8                                                                           @appstream   
 
gcc-plugin-annobin.x86_64
8.5.0-21.el8                                                                           @baseos      
 
gcc-toolset-13.x86_64
13.0-2.el8                                                                             @@commandline
 
gcc-toolset-13-annobin-docs.noarch
12.32-2.el8                                                                            @appstream   
 
gcc-toolset-13-annobin-plugin-gcc.x86_64
12.32-2.el8                                                                            @appstream   
 
gcc-toolset-13-binutils.x86_64
2.40-15.el8                                                                            @appstream   
 
gcc-toolset-13-binutils-gold.x86_64
2.40-15.el8                                                                            @appstream   
 
gcc-toolset-13-dwz.x86_64
0.14-0.el8                                                                             @appstream   
 
gcc-toolset-13-gcc.x86_64
13.2.1-6.el8                                                                           @appstream   
 
gcc-toolset-13-gcc-c++.x86_64
13.2.1-6.el8                                                                           @appstream   
 
gcc-toolset-13-gcc-gfortran.x86_64
13.2.1-6.el8                                                                           @appstream   
 
gcc-toolset-13-gdb.x86_64
12.1-4.el8                                                                             @appstream   
 
gcc-toolset-13-libquadmath-devel.x86_64
13.2.1-6.el8                                                                           @appstream   
 
gcc-toolset-13-libstdc++-devel.x86_64
13.2.1-6.el8                                                                           @appstream   
 
gcc-toolset-13-runtime.x86_64
13.0-2.el8                                                                             @appstream   
 




-----Original Message-----
From: Thomas Munro <thomas.munro@gmail.com> 
Sent: Friday, January 12, 2024 10:34 PM
To: Fensterman, John P <John.Fensterman@charter.com>; pgsql-bugs@lists.postgresql.org
Subject: [EXTERNAL] Re: BUG #18289: postgresql14-devel-14.10-2PGDG.rhel8.x86_64.rpm Contains invalid cLang option in
Makefile.global

CAUTION: The e-mail below is from an external source. Please exercise caution before opening attachments, clicking
links,or following guidance.
 

On Sat, Jan 13, 2024 at 7:34 AM PG Bug reporting form <noreply@postgresql.org> wrote:
> make
> /usr/bin/clang -Wno-ignored-attributes -fno-strict-aliasing -fwrapv 
> -fexcess-precision=standard -Xclang -no-opaque-pointers 
> -Wno-unused-command-line-argument -Wno-compound-token-split-by-macro
> -Wno-deprecated-non-prototype -O2  -I. -I./ 
> -I/usr/pgsql-14/include/server -I/usr/pgsql-14/include/internal  
> -D_GNU_SOURCE -I/usr/include/libxml2 -I/usr/include -flto=thin 
> -emit-llvm -c -o temporal_tables.bc temporal_tables.c
> error: unknown argument: '-no-opaque-pointers'

Which version of clang is that?  And can you tell from any of the artefacts in that -devel package which version of
clangwas used when it was configured?
 

LLVM 13-15 had optional opaque pointers, and LLVM 16+ required them.
We only started using them when they were absolutely required, at the same time as we added support for LLVM 16.  Since
weweren't sure what might break if we changed the behaviour with already-released code, eg .bc files that might be part
ofan extension, we figured it would be best to keep using -no-opaque-pointers with older clangs that will accept it.
Thereis a test in the configure script:
 

checking whether /usr/bin/clang supports -Xclang -no-opaque-pointers, for BITCODE_CFLAGS... (cached) no checking
whether/usr/bin/clang -xc++ supports -Xclang -no-opaque-pointers, for BITCODE_CXXFLAGS... (cached) no
 

Now if the package maintainer used a different major version of clang than you're using to compile your extension, it
mayhave some compiler flags that your compiler doesn't like.  I guess that problem is more general than LLVM, though?
 
E-MAIL CONFIDENTIALITY NOTICE: 
The contents of this e-mail message and any attachments are intended solely for the addressee(s) and may contain
confidentialand/or legally privileged information. If you are not the intended recipient of this message or if this
messagehas been addressed to you in error, please immediately alert the sender by reply e-mail and then delete this
messageand any attachments. If you are not the intended recipient, you are notified that any use, dissemination,
distribution,copying, or storage of this message or any attachment is strictly prohibited.