"(But I too would not use Postgres-over-NFS for any critical data. Too many moving parts. It's tough enough to ensure crash safety with local storage.)"
You're going through a lot of security effort to implement a Worst Practice.
On Wed, Jul 16, 2025 at 9:25 AM Amol Inamdar <amol.aai@gmail.com> wrote:
Hi All,
I would like to rephrase the question a little bit, below is how our setup going to be
NFS mount point is for /nfs-mount/postgres (and permissions locked down so that Postgres cannot create directories in here)
Postgres data directory is /nfs-mount/postgres/db
With secured NFS + AT-TLS setup Postgres will be able to write to data directory but not parent dir, however the file ownership information Postgres sees from the stat() call will not match the Postgres user in the container (even though the AT-TLS strict access control will ensure only the Posgres user can read/write to this directory)
Considering the above scenario/setup, what is the danger of removing the ownership check in miscinit.c checkDataDir() function ?
On Tue, Jul 15, 2025 at 5:06 PM Amol Inamdar <amol.aai@gmail.com> wrote:
Thanks Tom and Laurenz for the explanation.
Let me try out a few things and get back to you if needed.
Laurenz Albe <laurenz.albe@cybertec.at> writes: > It is not a good idea to have a mount point be the data directory.
^^^ This. ^^^
That is primarily for safety reasons: if for some reason the filesystem gets dismounted, or hasn't come on-line yet during a reboot, you do not want Postgres to be able to write on the underlying mount-point directory. There is a sobering tale in this old thread:
Now it didn't help any that they were using a start script that would automatically run initdb if it didn't see a data directory where expected. But even without that, you are in for a world of hurt if the mount drops while the server is running and the server has any ability to write on the underlying storage; it will think whatever it was able to write is safely down on disk. To prevent that, the server must not have write permissions on the mount point, which dictates making a separate data directory (with different ownership/permissions) just below the mount.
Do not bypass that ownership/permissions check. It is there for very good reasons.
