Re: No Issue Tracker - Say it Ain't So! - Mailing list pgsql-hackers

On 09/29/2015 07:25 AM, Merlin Moncure wrote:
> On Wed, Sep 23, 2015 at 1:18 PM, Kam Lasater <ckl@seekayel.com> wrote:
>> Hello,
>>
>> Last night I heard that Postgres had no issue/bug tracker. At first I
>> thought the guy was trolling me. Seriously, how could this be. Certainly a
>> mature open source project that is the database for a measurable percentage
>> of the internet would have an issue tracker.
>>
>> Sadly, I was not being trolled. I'm new around here so I will keep the
>> preaching to a minimum and cut right to the chase...
>>
>> ___It is time for an issue tracker___
>
> This thread is depressing me.  We use all these fancy tools at $work
> and I'm not sure they are much of an improvement over informal
> processes run by capable people.   I regularly advocate, pretty much
> to the wind, to use JIRA less and email *more*.   The main benefit of
> the system, various reports to corporate taskmasters, seems pretty
> much irrelevant here.  If you're advocating introduction of new
> tooling with all the associated processes and complexities, can you
> point to specific breakdowns in the project and exactly how said
> tooling would have helped the situation?
From my perspective this is about more than bugs it is about 
development as a whole. Here is a very simple problem we have:

I come to hackers to discuss an idea
idea gets sign off
I submit a patch
*I am told to go over to this commitfest app thing and upload it there*

Why? That's stupid. I should have submitted the patch to hackers and it 
should have been automatically part of my existing thread.

Someone reviews the patch, decides it needs to be pushed to the next 
commitfest

In theory, at some point I will be informed of that or I will see that 
it was pushed to the next commitfest.

If we were running a properly integrated tracker, I would know that 
instantly because the issue would have been updated to the affect and 
marked for the next commitfest.

The next commitfest comes around, and I can't get to the patch changes 
in time so it gets pushed to the next release. With a properly 
integrated issue tracker, I would immediately see that, be able to 
comment on it and be able to see the entire history of the patch.

Oh... and this can be done all from email as long as the tracker is 
properly integrated.

Bugs can certainly be handled the same way and in some ways better.

JD

P.S. I am not complaining about the commitfest process, I am making 
remarks about the tools we are using to manage it.


>
> merlin
>
>


-- 
Command Prompt, Inc. - http://www.commandprompt.com/  503-667-4564
PostgreSQL Centered full stack support, consulting and development.
Announcing "I'm offended" is basically telling the world you can't
control your own emotions, so everyone else should do it for you.