On Wed, 2007-01-17 at 15:58, Steve wrote:
> On Wed, 17 Jan 2007, Benjamin Minshall wrote:
>
> >
> >> Building these indexes takes forever!
> >
> >> Anyway -- ANYTHING we can do to make this go faster is appreciated :)
> >> Here's some vital statistics:
> >
> >> - Machine is a 16 GB, 4 actual CPU dual-core opteron system using SCSI
> >> discs. The disc configuration seems to be a good one, it's the best of all
> >> the ones we've tested so far.
> >
> > What are your shared_buffers, work_mem, and maintenance_work_mem settings?
> >
> > maintenance_work_mem is used for CREATE INDEX, and with 16GB of memory in the
> > machine, maintenance_work_mem should be set to at least 1GB in my opinion.
> >
>
> shared_buffers = 8GB
> work_mem = 256MB
> maintenance_work_mem = 6GB
>
> So that should be covered, unless I'm using too much memory and swapping.
> It does look like it's swapping a little, but not too badly as far as I
> can tell. I'm thinking of dialing back everything a bit, but I'm not
> really sure what the heck to do :) It's all guessing for me right now.
Generally speaking, once you've gotten to the point of swapping, even a
little, you've gone too far. A better approach is to pick some
conservative number, like 10-25% of your ram for shared_buffers, and 1
gig or so for maintenance work_mem, and then increase them while
exercising the system, and measure the difference increasing them makes.
If going from 1G shared buffers to 2G shared buffers gets you a 10%
increase, then good. If going from 2G to 4G gets you a 1.2% increase,
it's questionable. You should reach a point where throwing more
shared_buffers stops helping before you start swapping. But you might
not.
Same goes for maintenance work mem. Incremental changes, accompanied by
reproduceable benchmarks / behaviour measurements are the way to
determine the settings.
Note that you can also vary those during different times of the day.
you can have maint_mem set to 1Gig during the day and crank it up to 8
gig or something while loading data. Shared_buffers can't be changed
without restarting the db though.
