Gathering some of the threads, here's what I see:
1. There is some demand for per database logging. Doing that is rather
beyond the scope of what I intended - in fact what I intended was to enable
sensible log splitting out of band. I'll even write a perl script to do it
for you if you like :-)
2. There is a suggestion of custom log formats, beyond the current on/off
flags used, similar to Apache's logging mechanism. Of course, there are some
problems - web logs cover one thing - http transactions. Even there, custom
logging has led people to grief, and led to the common logging format that
web log analysers usually use. And Pg logs cover various kinds of events.
Some don't have a sensible db name, for example (like server startup logs
messages). Writing code that would allow administrators to specify the log
format almost arbitrarily, or even just to order the fields arbitrarily,
would be quite a bit of work, and I suspect a constant source of irritating
bugs, and I have no interest in doing the work. There are far more valuable
things that need to be done.
3. There is debate about field delimiters in the logs. Currently, timestamp
when used is a fixed length field at the start of the record, and pid when
used is inside [ ]. This is complicated in the case of dbname by the facts
that a) dbnames can be almost anything and b) not all records will have a
(sensible) dbname to report. I chose [ ] originally to conform to what was
done with pid, but now I'm leaning towards something else - too many M$
people have used [ ] in db work for years, so it is likely to crop up in
names somehow. Maybe < > or | | - whatever seems least liketo to occur
inside a dbname. I want to logs to be readable as well as parseable, or I'd
use something like ^ or ~ or `. The other reason to move away from [ ] is
that Tom (quite reasonably) wants to keep the char count down, and that
would let me drop the "db:" prefix, so the fixed overhead would be 3 chars
per line instead of 6 (if you count the trailing space).
The bottom line for me is to get the info needed in the logs, and then make
them look pretty, split them, or whatever, out of band - that isn't (and
shouldn't, IMNSHO) be the server's job.
andrew
