how to control the execution plan ? - Mailing list pgsql-sql

From Sabin Coanda
Subject how to control the execution plan ?
Date
Msg-id g4smp1$185p$1@news.hub.org
Whole thread Raw
Responses Re: how to control the execution plan ?
List pgsql-sql
Hi there,

I try to execute the following statement:

SELECT *
FROM (   SELECT "MY_FUNCTION_A"(bp."COL_A", NULL::boolean) AS ALIAS_A   FROM "TABLE_A" bp       JOIN "TABLE_B" pn ON
bp."COL_B"= pn."PK_ID"       JOIN "TABLE_C" vbo ON bp."COL_C" = vbo."PK_ID"   WHERE pn."Editor"::text ~~ 'Some%'::text
ANDbp."COL_A" IS NOT NULL AND 
 
bp."COL_A"::text <> ''::text
) x
WHERE (x.ALIAS_A::text ) IS NULL;

The problem is the excution plan first make Seq Scan on "TABLE_A", with 
Filter: (("COL_A" IS NOT NULL) AND (("COL_A")::text <> ''::text) AND 
(("MY_FUNCTION_A"("COL_A", NULL::boolean))::text IS NULL))". This way, 
MY_FUNCTION_A crashes for some unsupported data provided by  "COL_A".

I'd like to get an execution plan which is filtering first the desired rows, 
and just after that compute te column value "MY_FUNCTION_A"(bp."COL_A", 
NULL::boolean).

I made different combinations, including a subquery like:

SELECT *
FROM (   SELECT "MY_FUNCTION_A"(y."COL_A", NULL::boolean) AS ALIAS_A   FROM (       SELECT bp."COL_A"       FROM
"TABLE_A"bp           JOIN "TABLE_B" pn ON bp."COL_B" = pn."PK_ID"           JOIN "TABLE_C" vbo ON bp."COL_C" =
vbo."PK_ID"      WHERE pn."COL_E"::text ~~ 'Some%'::text AND bp."COL_A" IS NOT NULL 
 
AND bp."COL_A"::text <> ''::text   ) y
) x
WHERE (x.ALIAS_A::text ) IS NULL;

but postgres analyze is too 'smart' and optimize it as in the previous case, 
with the same Seq Scan on "TABLE_A", and with the same filter.

I thought to change the function MY_FUNCTION_A, to support any argument 
data, but the even that another performance problem will be rised when the 
function will be computed for any row in join, even those that can be 
removed by other filter.

Do you have a solution please ?

TIA
Sabin 




pgsql-sql by date:

Previous
From: Craig Ringer
Date:
Subject: Re: How to find space occupied by postgres on harddisk
Next
From: "Scott Marlowe"
Date:
Subject: Re: how to control the execution plan ?