> -----Original Message-----
> From: David Fetter [mailto:david@fetter.org]
> Sent: 21 March 2006 16:45
> To: Dave Page
> Cc: PostgreSQL WWW
> Subject: Re: [pgsql-www] human validation on post comments
>
> The porn thing works just fine no matter what the timeout is, as the
> spam is queued up already and the capcha gets presented as soon as
> it's generated. The porn surfer will generally not dally when
> presented with the capcha.
Generating enough real traffic to a dummy site to ensure that there is
always user ready to read a single capcha within a few minutes of it
being generated just to post a single piece of spam seems like a pretty
mean feat. I would think they could generate more revenue from bunging a
few ads on the site than hoping that the spam they manage to get on a
completely unrelated site might actually generate a customer. Still, I'm
only speculating so may be completely wrong.
> But apart from its ineffectiveness on spammers, as others have
> mentioned, capcha excludes blind people. :(
Yes - it's a shame none of us thought about it when Gevik was originally
working on it.
There is the audio option I suggested which Paypal use IIRC -
alternatively we could use some sort of puzzle - such as 'enter the
third, second from last and 2nd character from this string'.
Regards, Dave.
