Re: Hackorum - a new mailing list frontend - Mailing list pgsql-hackers

Hello!

Thank you for all the feedback so far!



David Geier <geidav.pg@gmail.com> wrote:

> - Threads with more than a couple of messages take a very long time to load

While the performance stabilized after the initial issues, generally
the speed of hackorum should be a lot faster now after a few
performance fixes, both for the index and the topic views.

> - I find it difficult to match the thread outline to the actual message. Making a visual connection between the
threadoutline and the currently viewed message would be helpful.
 

Done! To be honest, I'm not entirely happy with the topic
view/outline, but I also don't know how to make it significantly
better.

For now:

* message headers include the same colors as the outline view
* the currently visible message is highlighted in the outline

I hope this helps match the two together.

If you have any other ideas, please share, maybe we can make it even better.



Marcos Pegoraro <marcos@f10.com.br> wrote:

> Maybe an option to show in descending order and show only the first 10 or 20 messages
> Sometimes there are hundreds of messages on that thread, so this way would be faster and would show the current
statusof it and not how it started.
 

We had multiple listing options in an earlier version, but it can be
confusing - the outline and the actual messages would go in a
different order.

But the idea about "showing the current status" sounds interesting,
I'm playing with the idea of some automatic grouping based on date
period (months/years) and automatically collapsing older entries
(especially if all read already) could work.



Nico Williams <nico@cryptonector.com> wrote:

> This one feature in particular is very nice.  I wonder if you can make it so you can subscribe in the sense of being
anapproved sender but not in the sense of getting copies sent.
 

I don't understand this question, subscribe where? If you mean to the
mailing list, you can turn off receiving messages in the settings, and
you can still continue sending emails. That's how I've been using the
list since I started using hackorum. If I want to reply to a new
thread where I don't have a local email yet, I'm using the "resend
email" (paper plane icon) in hackorum to get an email, and then I can
reply as normally from my email client.

> A read-only IMAP/JMAP server might also be nice, especially if it could mark messages as read/replied-to/marked like
this. But yeah, the web interface is not limited by IMAP/JMAP and can do so much more.
 

IMAP/JMAP are also much more complex than just marking messages read,
I'm not sure how well that would work out. For now, we have the CSV
import option, and I plan to release a downloadable script in the near
future that generates CSVs using IMAP for initial status import.



Other than the performance fix and outline change I mentioned above,
hackorum now also has a button to download the latest patchset as a
single tar.gz file for every topic.

There is also a downloadable script that helps with adding it to a
local git checkout automatically, works with all attachments, doesn't
require a commitfest entry. It's available and documented at:
https://hackorum.dev/help/hackorum-patch