(1) I can (and do) use psql, pg_isready seems lighter and since it already supports credentials and DB name, I see very little harm for pg_isready to say back whether user logged IN or not using these credentials.
(2) timeout is not the same - timeout does not retry, its a simple timeout in case connection hangs, try it
That threw me recently, too.
If your DB is in recovery, pg_isready with a long timeout won't wait until it's accepting normal user connections or until timeout. There's no way to get that behaviour without a shell script loop or similar.
