On Sat, May 16, 2015 at 5:58 PM, Tom Lane <tgl@sss.pgh.pa.us> wrote:
With feature freeze behind us, I'd like to propose that now is a good time for a pgindent run. It's possible we'd need another one before 9.5 is branched off from HEAD, but a run now ought to take care of 95% of the cleanup needed. I see a couple of advantages to doing it now:
1. Patches that are now postponed to 9.6 will need to be rebased against pgindented sources anyway. Might as well give their authors more time for that rather than less.
2. Code that matches the project layout conventions is easier to read and review, IMO (not that I'm especially in love with the pgindent layout, but I'm used to it). Also any issues like commit d678bde65 would be taken care of, which is an objective reason why reviewing is easier.
The only significant downside I can think of is that, if we determine that any of the recent feature additions are so sketchy that they need to be reverted, having to undo just a portion of the pgindent commit before reverting the feature commit would be a pain. But I don't think we should optimize on the assumption that that will happen.
+1, except I suggest we at least delay it until we have wrapped the new minor releases, to make sure we don't conflict with any backpatching there.
