On Sun, Apr 3, 2022 at 12:03 PM Tom Lane <tgl@sss.pgh.pa.us> wrote:
>
> I wrote:
> > Joseph Koshakow <koshy44@gmail.com> writes:
> >> I think I know that the issue is. It's with `ParseISO8601Number` and
> >> the minutes field "1.".
> >> Previously that function parsed the entire field into a single double,
> >> so "1." would
> >> be parsed into 1.0. Now we try to parse the integer and decimal parts
> >> separately. So
> >> we first parse "1" into 1 and then fail to "." into anything because
> >> it's not a valid decimal.
>
> > Interesting point, but then why doesn't it fail everywhere?
>
> Oh ... a bit of testing says that strtod() on an empty string
> succeeds (returning zero) on Linux, but fails with EINVAL on
> AIX. The latter is a lot less surprising than the former,
> so we'd better cope.
>
> (Reading POSIX with an eagle eye, it looks like both behaviors
> are allowed per spec: this is why you have to check that endptr
> was advanced to be sure everything is kosher.)
>
> regards, tom lane
I'm not sure I follow exactly. Where would we pass an empty
string to strtod()? Wouldn't we be passing a string with a
single character of '.'?
Either way, from reading the man pages though it seems
that strtod() has the same behavior on any invalid input in
Linux, return 0 and don't advance endptr.
So I think we need to check that endptr has moved both after
the call to strtoi64() and strtod().
- Joe Koshakow
