> On 11 Feb 2026, at 21:19, Tom Lane <tgl@sss.pgh.pa.us> wrote:
>
> Daniel Gustafsson <daniel@yesql.se> writes:
>> [ v4 patches for better timeout handling ]
>
> I got around to reviewing these finally. v4-0001 looks good, except
> that there is now another copy of the same logic in 030_pager.pl
> which should be fixed in the same way. Proposed revision to do that
> attached.
LGTM.
> I'm not very comfortable with v4-0002, specifically the decision
> that sub query and sub query_until should now return undef instead
> of dying. I think that next to no call sites will handle that well.
> Also, as this stands both subs will fail to reset $self->{stdout},
> pretty much guaranteeing that the next query will fail too.
> (Although if psql is stuck, do we have any chance at all of
> subsequent tests succeeding? Dying might be superior to spewing
> a bunch of content-free follow-on failures.)
IIRC the rationale was (but it's been a while so..) to catch queries which had
incorrect end criteria and report as error instead, but that will perhaps
mostly be found during hacking and dying isn't really a problem there.
> a1d7ae2b2 already made what I think is the critical debuggability
> improvement in sub query, namely to not die until after reporting
> whatever we got from the query. I'm inclined to suggest that
> sub query_until should be made to print a similar report, but
> still die on timeout.
Agreed, that's a solid improvement.
--
Daniel Gustafsson
