enable fallthrough warnings on clang - Mailing list pgsql-hackers

From Peter Eisentraut
Subject enable fallthrough warnings on clang
Date
Msg-id 76a8efcd-925a-4eaf-bdd1-d972cd1a32ff@eisentraut.org
Whole thread Raw
Responses Re: enable fallthrough warnings on clang
List pgsql-hackers
The warnings about fallthrough in switch statements currently only work 
on gcc.  It would be nice if they also worked on clang, and in the long 
run other compilers.

gcc has a convention of annotation with comments, like /*fallthrough*/, 
but that is not available in other compilers.  The standard for this is 
using attributes, like [[fallthrough]] in C23 and C++, and 
__attribute__((fallthrough)) as extensions in gcc and clang.  (MSVC 
doesn't have anything like this in C mode, but it supports 
[[fallthrough]] in C++, so there is a plausible path to get this into C 
sometime as well.)

So my proposal is that we wrap the appropriate attribute into a 
pg_fallthrough macro, and replace the current comments with that.

There is a bit of fiddliness in setting the right compiler warning 
option.  You need -Wimplicit-fallthrough=5 with gcc, but 
-Wimplicit-fallthrough with clang, but you don't want the latter with 
gcc, because that doesn't enforce the use of the attribute.

Also, I found some places where clang warns but gcc does not, so there 
are patches to also fix those.  (These appear to be bugs in gcc.)

Attachment

pgsql-hackers by date:

Previous
From: Soumya S Murali
Date:
Subject: Re: Allowing ALTER COLUMN TYPE for columns in publication column lists
Next
From: Dean Rasheed
Date:
Subject: Re: commented out code