Re: generic modelling of data models; enforcing constraints dynamically... - Mailing list pgsql-general

From InterRob
Subject Re: generic modelling of data models; enforcing constraints dynamically...
Date
Msg-id 671e36b0909241327h33cbc993n4f63d2087a2f4ddb@mail.gmail.com
Whole thread Raw
In response to Re: generic modelling of data models; enforcing constraints dynamically...  (Ben Chobot <bench@silentmedia.com>)
List pgsql-general
Thank you, Ben. Well, I'm afraid you got the basic idea... I intend to implement a hybrid between a fixed schema and an Entity-Attribute-Value scheme. The schema will be able to cover 90% of the data needs; in other cases (specific projects) additional fields (and/or tables/relations) will be needed; including their constraints...

I'm experienting now with some smart thought that just came up: passing a set of key/value pairs to function that will test the new row; on insert / update the following could then be checked (as part of a RULE-set):

SELECT doesComply('relationname', keyValues.*) FROM (VALUES('col1', CAST(col1 AS TEXT)), VALUES('col2', CAST(col2 AS TEXT))) AS keyValues(the_key, the_value);

The function "doesComply()" will then process the CONSTRAINTS table and raise an Error if the new / updated row does not fit...


Any thoughts?


Rob

2009/9/24 Ben Chobot <bench@silentmedia.com>
Rob Marjot wrote:
Thank you, Ben. Well, I'm afraid you got the basic idea... I intend to implement a hybrid between a fixed schema and an Entity-Attribute-Value scheme. The schema will be able to cover 90% of the data needs; in other cases (specific projects) additional fields (and/or tables/relations) will be needed; including their constraints...

If you absolutely must have a dynamic schema like this, and can't have a DBA simply add tables as needed, then I think it would be less work, overall, to create a schema that your application has DDL rights to, and then let it create and modify normal tables with normal constraints there.

There certainly are some cases where an EAV solution is the proper one, and yours may be one of them. But most aren't.


pgsql-general by date:

Previous
From: Sam Mason
Date:
Subject: Re: generic modelling of data models; enforcing constraints dynamically...
Next
From: InterRob
Date:
Subject: Re: generic modelling of data models; enforcing constraints dynamically...