Re: Drop set problem - pgAdmin / Slony I - Mailing list pgadmin-support

From Magnus Hagander
Subject Re: Drop set problem - pgAdmin / Slony I
Date
Msg-id 478CF9A4.4030902@hagander.net
Whole thread Raw
In response to Drop set problem - pgAdmin / Slony I  (Glyn Astill <glynastill@yahoo.co.uk>)
Responses Re: Drop set problem - pgAdmin / Slony I
List pgadmin-support
Glyn Astill wrote:
> Hi chaps,
> 
> I've noticed a problem as described below with regards to adding
> replication 
> sets from within pgAdmin. I originally posted on the slony I general
> list, 
> and Christopher Browne suggested I ask you guys.
> 
> I set up a replication cluster using the pgAdmin scripts, and added a
> replication set with some tables and sequences in it (table /sequence
> Ids 1 - 4). I've kept the Id numbers the same as the table Ids.
> 
> Then I added another set (Id 2), and added a table and a sequence
> with Id 5.
> 
> In my slony log I get the error:
> 
> "remoteWorkerThread_1: node -1 not found in runtime configuration"
> 
> Does anyone know what causes the error above? I've read that it
> indicates slony had a problem at a point whilst subscribing so it
> flipped the node number to -1 to stop any further steps happening,
> however this doesn't help me track down what caused it.

Hm. Never seen that one.


> No "drop set" option seems to exist from with pgAdmin (although I'm 
> pretty sure I saw it once - are their criteria that make it appear?),

You can only drop a set if it has no subscribers. You have to drop the 
subscriber first. Could that be your problem here?



> so I did a "DROP SET ( ID=2, ORIGIN=1 );" using slonik on the origin,
> and 
> the set was removed from the origin, but it's still visible 
> (using pgadmin) on the subscriber (I have restarted the slons).
> I notice this error occours periodically now in the slony
> logs, so it seems the subscriber is trying to subscribe it?  E.g.
> 
> ------------------------------------------------------
> 
> 2008-01-15_144529 GMT DEBUG2 syncThread: new sl_action_seq 1 - SYNC
> 38491
> 2008-01-15_144533 GMT DEBUG1 copy_set 2
> 2008-01-15_144533 GMT ERROR  remoteWorkerThread_1: node -1 not found
> in runtime configuration
> 2008-01-15_144533 GMT WARN   remoteWorkerThread_1: data copy for set
> 2 failed - sleep 60 seconds
> WARNING:  there is no transaction in progress
> 
> ------------------------------------------------------
> 
> How do I remove this set from the subscriber?

I think it's somehow scheduled up behind whatever that thing going for 
node -1 is looking. If you can get rid of that one from sl_listen, I bet 
the set dropping will go through.


> I've had this happen before. Removing the cluster and setting it up
> again resolves the problem, however once we are in a production
> environment I can't go dropping the whole cluster and replicating all
> the tables from scratch when it happens.

Can you give us an exact step-by-step on how to make it happen?

//Magnus


pgadmin-support by date:

Previous
From: Glyn Astill
Date:
Subject: Drop set problem - pgAdmin / Slony I
Next
From: Glyn Astill
Date:
Subject: Re: Drop set problem - pgAdmin / Slony I