"J. R. Nield" <jrnield@usol.com> writes:
>> Uh, why? Why not just force a checkpoint and remember the exact
>> location of the checkpoint within the current log file?
> If I do a backup with PITR and save it to tape, I need to be able to
> restore it even if my machine is destroyed in a fire, and all the logs
> since the end of a backup are destroyed.
And for your next trick, restore it even if the backup tape itself is
destroyed. C'mon, be a little reasonable here. The backups and the
log archive tapes are *both* critical data in any realistic view of
the world.
> Is the complexity really that big of a problem with this?
Yes, it is. Didn't you just admit to struggling with bugs introduced
by exactly this complexity?? I don't care *how* spiffy the backup
scheme is, if when push comes to shove my backup doesn't restore because
there was a software bug in the backup scheme. In this context there
simply is not any virtue greater than "simple and reliable".
regards, tom lane
