Re: Any better plan for this query?..

From: Tom Lane
Subject: Re: Any better plan for this query?..
Date: ,
Msg-id: 20444.1242146977@sss.pgh.pa.us
(view: Whole thread, Raw)
In response to: Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Heikki Linnakangas)
Responses: Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Greg Stark)
Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Robert Haas)
List: pgsql-performance

Tree view

Any better plan for this query?..  (Dimitri, )
 Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Craig Ringer, )
  Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Dimitri, )
   Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Chris, )
    Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Dimitri, )
     Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Richard Huxton, )
     Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Craig Ringer, )
      Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Kenneth Marshall, )
       Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Matthew Wakeling, )
      Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Dimitri, )
  Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Kenneth Marshall, )
 Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Heikki Linnakangas, )
  Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Dimitri, )
   Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Simon Riggs, )
    Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Dimitri, )
     Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Merlin Moncure, )
      Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Dimitri, )
       Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Simon Riggs, )
        Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Dimitri, )
         Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Tom Lane, )
          Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Dimitri, )
          Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Simon Riggs, )
         Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Merlin Moncure, )
         Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Simon Riggs, )
          Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Dimitri, )
         Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Aidan Van Dyk, )
          Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Dimitri, )
           Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Alvaro Herrera, )
            Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Dimitri, )
             Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Dimitri Fontaine, )
              Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Dimitri, )
               Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Simon Riggs, )
                Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Dimitri, )
                 Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Simon Riggs, )
               Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Heikki Linnakangas, )
                Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Dimitri, )
                 Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Simon Riggs, )
                  Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Dimitri, )
                   Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Simon Riggs, )
                    Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Dimitri, )
                     Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Simon Riggs, )
                      Re: Any better plan for this query?..  ("Dave Dutcher", )
                       Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Dimitri, )
                        Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Merlin Moncure, )
                         Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Dimitri, )
                          Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Merlin Moncure, )
                           Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Dimitri, )
                            Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Merlin Moncure, )
                      Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Dimitri, )
                       Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Simon Riggs, )
                        Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Dimitri, )
                         Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Dimitri, )
                          Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Simon Riggs, )
                           Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Dimitri, )
                      Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Tom Lane, )
                       Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Dimitri, )
                       Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Simon Riggs, )
                        Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Matthew Wakeling, )
                         Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Simon Riggs, )
                          Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Simon Riggs, )
                          Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Matthew Wakeling, )
                           Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Simon Riggs, )
                           Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Scott Carey, )
                          Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Robert Haas, )
                        Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Tom Lane, )
                         Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Simon Riggs, )
                          Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Tom Lane, )
                           Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Robert Haas, )
                            Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Simon Riggs, )
                             Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Robert Haas, )
                              Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Simon Riggs, )
                     Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Scott Carey, )
                      Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Dimitri, )
                       Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Scott Carey, )
                        Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Dimitri, )
                         Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Scott Carey, )
                          Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Dimitri, )
               Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Simon Riggs, )
                Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Dimitri, )
                 Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Robert Haas, )
                  Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Dimitri, )
                   Re: Any better plan for this query?..  ("Kevin Grittner", )
                   Re: Any better plan for this query?..  ("Joshua D. Drake", )
                    Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Dimitri, )
                   Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Robert Haas, )
                    Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Dimitri, )
               Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Stefan Kaltenbrunner, )
                Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Dimitri, )
                 Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Stefan Kaltenbrunner, )
                  Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Matthew Wakeling, )
                   Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Simon Riggs, )
                    Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Matthew Wakeling, )
                     Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Stefan Kaltenbrunner, )
                     Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Tom Lane, )
                      Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Robert Haas, )
                  Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Dimitri, )
   Re: Any better plan for this query?..  ("Joshua D. Drake", )
           Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Heikki Linnakangas, )
            Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Dimitri, )
           Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Andres Freund, )
            Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Alvaro Herrera, )
             Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Scott Carey, )
              Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Dimitri, )
               Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Scott Carey, )
                Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Dimitri Fontaine, )
                 Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Dimitri, )
                 Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Simon Riggs, )
                Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Dimitri, )
    Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Gregory Stark, )
     Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Simon Riggs, )
  Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Matthew Wakeling, )
  Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Tom Lane, )
   Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Greg Stark, )
   Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Robert Haas, )
  Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Simon Riggs, )
   Re: Any better plan for this query?..  ("Joshua D. Drake", )
    Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Aidan Van Dyk, )
     Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Stephen Frost, )
   Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Robert Haas, )
   Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Glenn Maynard, )
    Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Dimitri, )
    Re: Any better plan for this query?..  ("Kevin Grittner", )
     Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Dimitri, )
      Re: Any better plan for this query?..  ("Kevin Grittner", )
  Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Dimitri Fontaine, )
   Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Alvaro Herrera, )
  Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Robert Haas, )
   Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Dimitri, )
 Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Dimitri, )
  Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Richard Huxton, )
  Re: Any better plan for this query?..  ("Albe Laurenz", )
   Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Dimitri, )
    Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Kenneth Marshall, )
 Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Merlin Moncure, )
  Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Merlin Moncure, )
   Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Dimitri, )
    Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Richard Huxton, )
     Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Ries van Twisk, )
      Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Dimitri, )
 Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Kenneth Marshall, )
  Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Dimitri, )
   Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Kenneth Marshall, )
 Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Dimitri, )
  Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Alvaro Herrera, )
 Re: Any better plan for this query?..  (Simon Riggs, )

Robert Haas <> writes:
> AIUI, whenever the connection pooler switches to serving a new client,
> it tells the PG backend to DISCARD ALL.  But why couldn't we just
> implement this same logic internally?  IOW, when a client disconnects,
> instead of having the backend exit immediately, have it perform the
> equivalent of DISCARD ALL and then stick around for a minute or two
> and, if a new connection request arrives within that time, have the
> old backend handle the new connection...

See previous discussions.  IIRC, there are two killer points:

1. There is no (portable) way to pass the connection from the postmaster
to another pre-existing process.

2. You'd have to track which database, and probably which user, each
such backend had been launched for; reconnecting a backend to a new
database is probably impractical and would certainly invalidate all
the caching.

Overall it looked like way too much effort for way too little gain.

            regards, tom lane


pgsql-performance by date:

From: Simon Riggs
Date:
Subject: Re: Any better plan for this query?..
From: Dimitri Fontaine
Date:
Subject: Re: Any better plan for this query?..