On Fri, Jul 20, 2012 at 12:39:12PM -0400, Aidan Van Dyk wrote:
> If you're wanting to automatically do some upgrades wouldn't an easier route be:
>
> 1) run pg_upgrade, up to the point where it actually start's
> copying/linking in old cluster data files, and stop the new
> postmaster.
> 2) Take a "base backup" style copy (tar, rsync, $FAVOURITE) of the new
> cluster (small, since without data files)
> 3) Have pg_upgrade leave a log of exactly which old cluster data files
> go where in the new cluster
>
> That way, anybody, any script, etc who wants to make a new "standby"
> from and old one only needs the pg_upgrade base backup (which should
> be small, no data, just catalog stuff), and the log of which old files
> to move where.
>
> The only pre-condition is that the standby's "old pg" *APPLIED* WAL up
> to the exact same point as the master's "old pg". In that case the
> standby's old cluster data files should same enough (maybe hint bits
> off?) to be used.
I am not sure what a base backup is buying us here --- base backup is
designed to create a backup while the server is running, and it is down
at that point. I think what you are suggesting is to make a data dir
copy while just the schema is in place. That is possible, but it opens
up all kinds of possible failure cases because pg_upgrade operations
have to be done in a specific order --- it feels very fragile.
I think the commands to run after pg_upgrade --link completes on both
primary and standby might be as easy as:
cd /u/pg/pgsql.old/datafind . -links 1 -exec cp {} /u/pgsql/data \;
Why would we want anything more complicated than this?
-- Bruce Momjian <bruce@momjian.us> http://momjian.us EnterpriseDB
http://enterprisedb.com
+ It's impossible for everything to be true. +
