TODO items - Mailing list pgsql-hackers

I am marking the completed TODO items.  Are these done?

    * Have standalone backend read postgresql.conf
    * Prevent whole-row references from leaking memory, e.g. SELECT
      COUNT(tab.*)
    * Use index to restrict rows returned by multi-key index when used with
      non-consecutive keys or OR clauses, so fewer heap accesses
    * Prevent index uniqueness checks when UPDATE does not modify the column
    * Return proper effected tuple count from complex commands [return]
    o Allow SHOW of non-modifiable variables, like pg_controldata
        o Allow array declarations and other data types in PL/PgSQL DECLARE
        o Add PL/PgSQL PROCEDURES that can return multiple values
        o Add table function support to pltcl, plperl, plpython
        o Allow PL/PgSQL to support array element assignment
    * Allow psql to do table completion for SELECT * FROM schema_part and
      table completion for SELECT * FROM schema_name.
        o Support jdbc both 'make' and 'ant'
    * Make blind writes go through the file descriptor cache
    * Improve Subplan list handling
    * Precompile SQL functions to avoid overhead (Neil)
    * Add optional CRC checksum to heap and index pages
        o Add optional textual message to NOTIFY

The current TODO is attached with completed items marked.

--
  Bruce Momjian                        |  http://candle.pha.pa.us
  pgman@candle.pha.pa.us               |  (610) 359-1001
  +  If your life is a hard drive,     |  13 Roberts Road
  +  Christ can be your backup.        |  Newtown Square, Pennsylvania 19073
TODO list for PostgreSQL
========================
Last updated:        Thu Aug  7 22:00:19 EDT 2003

Current maintainer:    Bruce Momjian (pgman@candle.pha.pa.us)

The most recent version of this document can be viewed at
the PostgreSQL web site, http://www.PostgreSQL.org.

A dash (-) marks changes that will appear in the upcoming 7.4 release.

Bracketed items "[]" have more detailed.


Urgent
======

* Add replication of distributed databases [replication]
    o Automatic failover
    o Load balancing
    o Master/slave replication
    o Multi-master replication
    o Partition data across servers
    o Sample implementation in contrib/rserv
    o Queries across databases or servers (two-phase commit)
    o Allow replication over unreliable or non-persistent links
    o http://gborg.postgresql.org/project/pgreplication/projdisplay.php
* Point-in-time data recovery using backup and write-ahead log
* Create native Win32 port [win32]


Reporting
=========

* -Allow elog() to return error codes, module name, file name, line
  number, not just messages (Tom)
* -Add error codes (Tom)
* -Make error messages more consistent
* Show location of syntax error in query [yacc]
* -Add GUC log_statement_and_duration to print statement and >= min duration


Administration
==============

* Incremental backups
* Remove unreferenced table files and temp tables during database vacuum
  or postmaster startup (Bruce)
* Remove behavior of postmaster -o after making postmaster/postgres
  flags unique
* Allow easy display of usernames in a group
* Allow configuration files to be specified in a different directory
* -Add start time to pg_stat_activity
* Allow limits on per-db/user connections
* Have standalone backend read postgresql.conf
* Add group object ownership, so groups can rename/drop/grant on objects,
  so we can implement roles
* Add the concept of dataspaces/tablespaces [tablespaces]
* -Allow CIDR format to be used in pg_hba.conf
* Allow logging of only data definition(DDL), or DDL and modification statements
* Allow log lines to include session-level information, like database and user
* Allow server log information to be output as INSERT statements


Data Types
==========

* -Add IPv6 capability to INET/CIDR types
* Remove Money type, add money formatting for decimal type
* Change factorial to return a numeric
* -Change NUMERIC data type to use base 10,000 internally
* Change NUMERIC to enforce the maximum precision, and increase it
* Add function to return compressed length of TOAST data values (Tom)
* Allow INET subnet tests using non-constants
* Add transaction_timestamp(), statement_timestamp(), clock_timestamp() functionality
* -Add GUC variables to control floating number output digits (Pedro Ferreira)
* Have sequence dependency track use of DEFAULT sequences, seqname.nextval
* Disallow changing default expression of a SERIAL column
* Allow infinite dates just like infinite timestamps
* Allow pg_dump to dump sequences using NO_MAXVALUE and NO_MINVALUE
* Allow better handling of numeric constants, type conversion [typeconv]
* Allow backend to output result sets in XML
* Prevent whole-row references from leaking memory, e.g. SELECT COUNT(tab.*)
* -Allow current datestyle to restrict dates;  prevent month/day swapping
  from making invalid dates valid
* -Prevent month/day swapping of ISO dates to make invalid dates valid
* Have initdb set DateStyle based on locale?
* -Delay resolution of array expression type so assignment coercion
  can be performed on empty array expressions (Joe)

* ARRAYS
    o Allow nulls in arrays
    o -Allow arrays to be ORDER'ed
    o Support construction of array result values in expressions

* BINARY DATA
    o Improve vacuum of large objects, like /contrib/vacuumlo
    o Add security checking for large objects
    o Make file in/out interface for TOAST columns, similar to large object
      interface (force out-of-line storage and no compression)
    o Auto-delete large objects when referencing row is deleted


Multi-Language Support
======================

* Add NCHAR (as distinguished from ordinary varchar),
* Allow LOCALE on a per-column basis, default to ASCII
* Support multiple simultaneous character sets, per SQL92
* Improve Unicode combined character handling
* Optimize locale to have minimal performance impact when not used (Peter E)
* Add octet_length_server() and octet_length_client() (Thomas, Tatsuo)
* Make octet_length_client the same as octet_length() (?)
* Prevent mismatch of frontend/backend encodings from converting bytea
  data from being interpreted as encoded strings
* -Remove Cyrillic recode support


Views / Rules
=============

* Automatically create rules on views so they are updateable, per SQL92 [view]
* Add the functionality for WITH CHECK OPTION clause of CREATE VIEW
* Allow NOTIFY in rules involving conditionals
* Have views on temporary tables exist in the temporary namespace
* Move psql backslash information into views
* Allow RULE recompilation


Indexes
=======

* Allow CREATE INDEX zman_index ON test (date_trunc( 'day', zman ) datetime_ops)
  fails index can't store constant parameters
* Order duplicate index entries by tid for faster heap lookups
* Allow inherited tables to inherit index, UNIQUE constraint, and primary
  key, foreign key  [inheritance]
* UNIQUE INDEX on base column not honored on inserts from inherited table
  INSERT INTO inherit_table (unique_index_col) VALUES (dup) should fail
  [inheritance]
* Add UNIQUE capability to non-btree indexes
* Add btree index support for reltime, tinterval, regproc
* Add rtree index support for line, lseg, path, point
* -Certain indexes will not shrink, e.g. indexes on ever-increasing
  columns and indexes with many duplicate keys
* Use indexes for min() and max() or convert to SELECT col FROM tab ORDER
  BY col DESC LIMIT 1 if appropriate index exists and WHERE clause acceptible
* Allow LIKE indexing optimization for non-ASCII locales
* Use index to restrict rows returned by multi-key index when used with
  non-consecutive keys or OR clauses, so fewer heap accesses
* Be smarter about insertion of already-ordered data into btree index
* Prevent index uniqueness checks when UPDATE does not modify the column
* Use bitmaps to fetch heap pages in sequential order [performance]
* Use bitmaps to combine existing indexes [performance]
* Improve handling of index scans for NULL
* Allow SELECT * FROM tab WHERE int2col = 4 to use int2col index, int8,
  float4, numeric/decimal too [optimizer]
* Add FILLFACTOR to btree index creation
* Add concurrency to GIST
* Improve concurrency of hash indexes (Neil)
* Allow a single index to index multiple tables (for inheritance and subtables)


Commands
========

* Add BETWEEN ASYMMETRIC/SYMMETRIC (Christopher)
* -Allow LIMIT/OFFSET to use expressions (Tom)
* CREATE TABLE AS can not determine column lengths from expressions [atttypmod]
* Allow UPDATE to handle complex aggregates [update]
* Allow command blocks to ignore certain types of errors
* Allow backslash handling in quoted strings to be disabled for portability
* Return proper effected tuple count from complex commands [return]
* Allow UPDATE, DELETE to handle table aliases for self-joins [delete]
* Add CORRESPONDING BY to UNION/INTERSECT/EXCEPT
* Allow REINDEX to rebuild all indexes, remove /contrib/reindex
* -Make a transaction-safe TRUNCATE (Rod)
* Add ROLLUP, CUBE, GROUPING SETS options to GROUP BY
* Add schema option to createlang
* Allow savepoints / nested transactions [transactions] (Bruce)
* Allow UPDATE tab SET ROW (col, ...) = (...) for updating multiple columns
* -Allow UPDATE to use SET col = DEFAULT
* -Add config variable to prevent auto-adding missing FROM-clause tables
* Allow SET CONSTRAINTS to be qualified by schema/table
* -Have SELECT '13 minutes'::interval display zero seconds in ISO datestyle
* Prevent COMMENT ON DATABASE from using a database name
* Add GUC variable to prevent waiting on locks


* ALTER
    o ALTER TABLE ADD COLUMN does not honor DEFAULT and non-CHECK CONSTRAINT
    o ALTER TABLE ADD COLUMN column DEFAULT should fill existing
      rows with DEFAULT value
    o ALTER TABLE ADD COLUMN column SERIAL doesn't create sequence because
          of the item above
    o --Add ALTER TABLE tab SET WITHOUT OIDS (Rod)
    o -Add ALTER SEQUENCE to modify min/max/increment/cache/cycle values
    o Have ALTER TABLE rename SERIAL sequences
    o Allow columns to be reordered using ALTER ... POSITION i col1 [,col2];
      have SELECT * and INSERT honor such ordering
    o Allow ALTER TABLE to modify column lengths and change to binary
      compatible types
    o Add ALTER DATABASE ... OWNER TO newowner

* CLUSTER
    o Automatically maintain clustering on a table
    o -Allow CLUSTER to cluster all tables (Alvaro Herrera)

* COPY
    o Allow dump/load of CSV format
    o Allow COPY to report error lines and continue;  optionally
      allow error codes to be specified; requires savepoints or can
      not be run in a multi-statement transaction
    o Allow COPY to understand \x as hex
    o Have COPY return number of rows loaded/unloaded

* CURSOR
    o Allow BINARY option to SELECT, just like DECLARE
    o -MOVE 0 should not move to end of cursor (Bruce)
    o Allow UPDATE/DELETE WHERE CURRENT OF cursor using per-cursor tid
      stored in the backend (Gavin)
    o Prevent DROP of table being referenced by our own open cursor
    o -Allow cursors outside transactions

* INSERT
    o Allow INSERT/UPDATE of system-generated oid value for a row
    o Allow INSERT INTO tab (col1, ..) VALUES (val1, ..), (val2, ..)
    o Allow INSERT/UPDATE ... RETURNING new.col or old.col; handle
      RULE cases (Philip)

* SHOW/SET
    o Add SET PERFORMANCE_TIPS option to suggest INDEX, VACUUM, VACUUM
      ANALYZE, and CLUSTER
    o Add SET SCHEMA
    o -Allow EXPLAIN EXECUTE to see prepared plans
    o Allow SHOW of non-modifiable variables, like pg_controldata

* SERVER-SIDE LANGUAGES
    o Allow PL/PgSQL's RAISE function to take expressions
    o Change PL/PgSQL to use palloc() instead of malloc()
    o Allow Java server-side programming, http://pljava.sourceforge.net
      [java]
    o Fix problems with complex temporary table creation/destruction
      without using PL/PgSQL EXECUTE, needs cache prevention/invalidation
        o Fix PL/pgSQL RENAME to work on variables other than OLD/NEW
    o Improve PL/PgSQL exception handling
    o Allow parameters to be specified by name and type during definition
    o Allow function parameters to be passed by name,
      get_employee_salary(emp_id => 12345, tax_year => 2001)
    o Add PL/PgSQL packages
    o Allow array declarations and other data types in PL/PgSQL DECLARE
    o Add PL/PgSQL PROCEDURES that can return multiple values
    o Add table function support to pltcl, plperl, plpython
    o -Make PL/PgSQL %TYPE schema-aware
    o Allow PL/PgSQL to support array element assignment
    o Add PL/PHP (Joe, Jan)
    o Allow PL/pgSQL to name columns by ordinal position, e.g. rec.(3)
    o Allow PL/pgSQL EXECUTE query_var INTO record_var;


Clients
=======

* -Allow psql to show transaction status if backend protocol changes made
* -Add schema, cast, and conversion backslash commands to psql (Christopher)
* -Allow pg_dump to dump a specific schema (Neil Conway)
* Allow psql to do table completion for SELECT * FROM schema_part and
  table completion for SELECT * FROM schema_name.
* Add XML capability to pg_dump and COPY, when backend XML capability
* -Allow SSL-enabled clients to turn off SSL transfers
* -Modify pg_get_triggerdef() to take a boolean to pretty-print,
  and use that as part of pg_dump along with psql



* JDBC
    o Comprehensive test suite. This may be available already.
    o JDBC-standard BLOB support
    o Error Codes (pending backend implementation)
    o Support both 'make' and 'ant'
    o Fix LargeObject API to handle OIDs as unsigned ints
    o Use cursors implicitly to avoid large results (see setCursorName())
    o Add LISTEN/NOTIFY support to the JDBC driver (Barry)

* ECPG
    o Docs
    o Implement set descriptor, using descriptor
    o Solve cardinality > 1 for input descriptors / variables
    o Improve error handling
    o Add a semantic check level, e.g. check if a table really exists
    o -Add SQLSTATE
    o fix handling of DB attributes that are arrays
    o Use backend prepare/execute facility for ecpg where possible
    o -Make casts work in variable initializations
    o -Implement SQLDA
    o Fix nested C comments
    o sqlwarn[6] should be 'W' if the PRECISION or SCALE value specified
    o -Allow multi-threaded use of SQLCA
    o -Understand structure definitions outside a declare section
    o -Allow :var[:index] or :var[<integer>] as cvariable for an array var

* Python
    o Allow users to register their own types with pg_
    o Allow SELECT to return a dictionary of dictionaries
    o Allow COPY BINARY FROM


Referential Integrity
=====================

* Add MATCH PARTIAL referential integrity [foreign]
* Add deferred trigger queue file (Jan)
* Implement dirty reads or shared row locks and use them in RI triggers
* Enforce referential integrity for system tables
* Change foreign key constraint for array -> element to mean element
  in array
* Allow DEFERRABLE UNIQUE constraints
* Allow triggers to be disabled [trigger]
* With disabled triggers, allow pg_dump to use ALTER TABLE ADD FOREIGN KEY
* -Support statement-level triggers (Neil)
* Support triggers on columns (Neil)
* Have AFTER triggers execute after the appropriate SQL statement in a
  function, not at the end of the function


Dependency Checking
===================

* Flush cached query plans when their underlying catalog data changes
* Use dependency information to dump data in proper order


Exotic Features
===============

* Add SQL99 WITH clause to SELECT (Tom, Fernando)
* Add SQL99 WITH RECURSIVE to SELECT (Tom, Fernando)
* Allow queries across multiple databases [crossdb]
* Add pre-parsing phase that converts non-ANSI features to supported features
* Allow plug-in modules to emulate features from other databases
* SQL*Net listener that makes PostgreSQL appear as an Oracle database
  to clients
* Two-phase commit to implement distributed transactions


PERFORMANCE
===========


Fsync
=====

* Delay fsync() when other backends are about to commit too [fsync]
    o Determine optimal commit_delay value
* Determine optimal fdatasync/fsync, O_SYNC/O_DSYNC options
    o Allow multiple blocks to be written to WAL with one write()


Cache
=====
* Shared catalog cache, reduce lseek()'s by caching table size in shared area
* Add free-behind capability for large sequential scans (Bruce)
* Consider use of open/fcntl(O_DIRECT) to minimize OS caching
* Make blind writes go through the file descriptor cache
* Cache last known per-tuple offsets to speed long tuple access
* Automatically place fixed-width, NOT NULL columns first in a table
* Consider using MVCC to cache count(*) queries with no WHERE clause


Vacuum
======

* Improve speed with indexes (perhaps recreate index instead) [vacuum]
* Reduce lock time by moving tuples with read lock, then write
  lock and truncate table [vacuum]
* Provide automatic running of vacuum in the background in backend
  rather than in /contrib [vacuum]
* Allow free space map to be auto-sized or warn when it is too small


Locking
=======

* Make locking of shared data structures more fine-grained
* Add code to detect an SMP machine and handle spinlocks accordingly
  from distributted.net, http://www1.distributed.net/source,
  in client/common/cpucheck.cpp
* Research use of sched_yield() for spinlock acquisition failure


Startup Time
============

* Experiment with multi-threaded backend [thread]
* Add connection pooling [pool]
* Allow persistent backends [persistent]
* Create a transaction processor to aid in persistent connections and
  connection pooling
* Do listen() in postmaster and accept() in pre-forked backend
* Have pre-forked backend pre-connect to last requested database or pass
  file descriptor to backend pre-forked for matching database


Write-Ahead Log
===============

* Have after-change WAL write()'s write only modified data to kernel
* Reduce number of after-change WAL writes; they exist only to gaurd against
  partial page writes [wal]
* Turn off after-change writes if fsync is disabled (?)
* Add WAL index reliability improvement to non-btree indexes
* Find proper defaults for postgresql.conf WAL entries
* -Add checkpoint_min_warning postgresql.conf option to warn about checkpoints
  that are too frequent (Bruce)
* Allow xlog directory location to be specified during initdb, perhaps
  using symlinks
* Allow WAL information to recover corrupted pg_controldata
* Find a way to reduce rotational delay when repeatedly writing
  last WAL page


Optimizer / Executor
====================

* Improve Subplan list handling
* -Allow Subplans to use efficient joins(hash, merge) with upper variable
* -Add hash for evaluating GROUP BY aggregates (Tom)
* -Allow merge and hash joins on expressions not just simple variables (Tom)
* -Make IN/NOT IN have similar performance to EXISTS/NOT EXISTS (Tom)
* Missing optimizer selectivities for date, r-tree, etc. [optimizer]
* Allow ORDER BY ... LIMIT to select top values without sort or index
  using a sequential scan for highest/lowest values (Oleg)
* -Inline simple SQL functions to avoid overhead (Tom)
* Precompile SQL functions to avoid overhead (Neil)
* Add utility to compute accurate random_page_cost value
* Improve ability to display optimizer analysis using OPTIMIZER_DEBUG
* Use CHECK constraints to improve optimizer decisions
* Check GUC geqo_threshold to see if it is still accurate
* Allow sorting, temp files, temp tables to use multiple work directories
* Improve the planner to use CHECK constraints to prune the plan (for subtables)


Miscellaneous
=============

* Do async I/O for faster random read-ahead of data
* -Get faster regex() code from Henry Spencer <henry@zoo.utoronto.ca>
* Use mmap() rather than SYSV shared memory or to write WAL files (?) [mmap]
* Improve caching of attribute offsets when NULLs exist in the row
* Add a script to ask system configuration questions and tune postgresql.conf
* Allow partitioning of table into multiple subtables


Source Code
===========

* Add use of 'const' for variables in source tree
* Rename some /contrib modules from pg* to pg_*
* Move some things from /contrib into main tree
* Remove warnings created by -Wcast-align
* Move platform-specific ps status display info from ps_status.c to ports
* -Modify regression tests to prevent failures do to minor numeric rounding
* -Add OpenBSD's getpeereid() call for local socket authentication
* Improve access-permissions check on data directory in Cygwin (Tom)
* Add documentation for perl, including mention of DBI/DBD perl location
* Create improved PostgreSQL introductory documentation for the PHP
  manuals (Rory)
* Add optional CRC checksum to heap and index pages
* Change representation of whole-tuple parameters to functions
* Clarify use of 'application' and 'command' tags in SGML docs
* Better document ability to build only certain interfaces (Marc)
* Remove or relicense modules that are not under the BSD license, if possible
* Remove memory/file descriptor freeing before ereport(ERROR)  (Bruce)
* Acquire lock on a relation before building a relcache entry for it
* Research interaction of setitimer() and sleep() used by statement_timeout
* Add checks for fclose() failure
* Change CVS $Id: TODO,v 1.1107 2003/08/08 02:00:20 momjian Exp $ to $PostgreSQL$
* Exit postmaster if postgresql.conf can not be opened
* Rename /scripts directory because they are all C programs now
* Allow the regression tests to start postmaster with -i so the tests
  can be run on systems that don't support unix-domain sockets
* Allow creation of a libpq-only tarball
* Promote debug_query_string into a server-side function current_query()
* Allow the identifier length to be increased via a configure option


* Wire Protocol Changes
    o -Show transaction status in psql
    o -Allow binding of query parameters, support for prepared queries
    o Add optional textual message to NOTIFY
    o -Remove hard-coded limits on user/db/password names
    o -Remove unused elements of startup packet (unused, tty, passlength)
    o -Fix COPY/fastpath protocol
    o Allow fastpast to pass values in portable format
    o -Error codes
    o Dynamic character set handling
    o Special passing of binary values in platform-neutral format (bytea?)
    o Add decoded type, length, precision
    o Compression?
    o -Report server version number, database encoding, client encoding
    o Update clients to use data types, typmod, schema.table.column names of
      result sets using new query protocol


---------------------------------------------------------------------------


Developers who have claimed items are:
--------------------------------------
* Barry is Barry Lind <barry@xythos.com>
* Billy is Billy G. Allie <Bill.Allie@mug.org>
* Bruce is Bruce Momjian <pgman@candle.pha.pa.us> of Software Research Assoc.
* Christopher is Christopher Kings-Lynne <chriskl@familyhealth.com.au> of
    Family Health Network
* D'Arcy is D'Arcy J.M. Cain <darcy@druid.net> of The Cain Gang Ltd.
* Dave is Dave Cramer <dave@fastcrypt.com>
* Edmund is Edmund Mergl <E.Mergl@bawue.de>
* Fernando is Fernando Nasser <fnasser@redhat.com> of Red Hat
* Gavin is Gavin Sherry <swm@linuxworld.com.au> of Alcove Systems Engineering
* Greg is Greg Sabino Mullane <greg@turnstep.com>
* Hiroshi is Hiroshi Inoue <Inoue@tpf.co.jp>
* Karel is Karel Zak <zakkr@zf.jcu.cz>
* Jan is Jan Wieck <JanWieck@Yahoo.com> of PeerDirect Corp.
* Liam is Liam Stewart <liams@redhat.com> of Red Hat
* Marc is Marc Fournier <scrappy@hub.org> of PostgreSQL, Inc.
* Mark is Mark Hollomon <mhh@mindspring.com>
* Michael is Michael Meskes <meskes@postgresql.org> of Credativ
* Neil is Neil Conway <neilc@samurai.com>
* Oleg is Oleg Bartunov <oleg@sai.msu.su>
* Peter M is Peter T Mount <peter@retep.org.uk> of Retep Software
* Peter E is Peter Eisentraut <peter_e@gmx.net>
* Philip is Philip Warner <pjw@rhyme.com.au> of Albatross Consulting Pty. Ltd.
* Rod is Rod Taylor <pg@rbt.ca>
* Ross is Ross J. Reedstrom <reedstrm@wallace.ece.rice.edu>
* Stephan is Stephan Szabo <sszabo@megazone23.bigpanda.com>
* Tatsuo is Tatsuo Ishii <t-ishii@sra.co.jp> of Software Research Assoc.
* Thomas is Thomas Lockhart <lockhart@fourpalms.org> of Jet Propulsion Labratory
* Tom is Tom Lane <tgl@sss.pgh.pa.us> of Red Hat
* Vadim is Vadim B. Mikheev <vadim4o@email.com> of Sector Data