Re: Can I get some PostgreSQL developer feedback on these five general issues I have with PostgreSQL and its ecosystem? - Mailing list pgsql-general

From Guyren Howe
Subject Re: Can I get some PostgreSQL developer feedback on these five general issues I have with PostgreSQL and its ecosystem?
Date
Msg-id 1055e3df-5be1-4d03-b8a0-bd613fe447da@Spark
Whole thread Raw
In response to Can I get some PostgreSQL developer feedback on these five general issues I have with PostgreSQL and its ecosystem?  (tutiluren@tutanota.com)
List pgsql-general
Regarding indexes, I recommend the website use-the-index-luke.com. That guy’s other website about modern SQL is also great.

Regarding self-tuning, it was actually part of the original vision for relational databases that they would do that, but I’m not aware of any modern SQL database that does, although there are third-party tools that will eg offer index suggestions (I don’t know which is best, so I won’t propose any).
On Sep 14, 2020, 13:22 -0700, tutiluren@tutanota.com, wrote:
4. There is no built-in means to have PG manage (or even suggest) indexes on its own. Trying to figure out what indexes to create/delete/fine-tune, and determine all the extremely complex rules for this art (yes, I just called index management an *art*, because it is!), is just utterly hopeless to me. It never gets any easier. Not even after many years. It's the by far worst part of databases to me (combined with point five). Having to use third-party solutions ensures that it isn't done in practice, at least for me. I don't trust, nor do I want to deal with, external software and extensions in my databases. I still have nightmares from PostGIS, which I only keep around, angrily, out of absolute necessity. I fundamentally don't like third-party add-ons to things, but want the core product to properly support things. Besides, this (adding/managing indexes) is not even some niche/obscure use-case, but something which is crucial for basically any nontrivial database of any kind!

pgsql-general by date:

Previous
From: Guyren Howe
Date:
Subject: Re: Can I get some PostgreSQL developer feedback on these five general issues I have with PostgreSQL and its ecosystem?
Next
From: Ravi Krishna
Date:
Subject: Re: Can I get some PostgreSQL developer feedback on these five general issues I have with PostgreSQL and its ecosystem?