From: pgsql-general-owner@postgresql.org
[mailto:pgsql-general-owner@postgresql.org] On Behalf Of Jan de Visser
OK, still not quite sure what your architecture is. Is it
(1)
+---------------+
| Client system |
+---------------+
|
v
+---------------+
| andl |
+---------------+
|
v (SQL)
+---------------+
| pgsql |
+---------------+
Or (2)
+---------------+
| Client system |
+---------------+
|
v (SQL)
+---------------+ +----------+
| driver/pgsql | -> | andl |
+---------------+ +----------+
In case (1), you're writing a driver: you abstract out the actual datastore
from your client program using andl. In case (2) you have a procedural
language handler where your client program still consciously connects to a
pgsql database, and within that database some/all data processing is
delegated to andl.
[dmb>] It's a fair question, and not obvious at various levels. The plan at
this stage is to continue to use as much of the Postgres client
infrastructure as possible, which means sticking with (2). The client will
definitely connect with a Postgres database and could use ODBC/JDBC/libpq or
whatever.
[dmb>] But the logical model is more like (1). Andl compiles into byte code
which is stored as functions in its catalog (which BTW is just another
Postgres table). The only useful SQL query is: "SELECT func(args);", which
executes an Andl function with some arguments and returns a result set. It
is not intended to ever embed an Andl function call into an SQL query as I
think is done with other languages.
[dmb>] But it would be equally possible to implement (1) directly, using the
Thrift interface (or something else that I haven't tripped over yet). I have
an Sqlite implementation that works like that.
The reason I'm asking is to set terminology. I've browsed some of your
website, and I'm still not clear which of the two options you're after. It
could even be both I think. So let's set some parameters.
[dmb>] The website always lags behind. I only started with Postgres about 2
weeks ago, and I really am only now getting a clear enough idea to be able
to write coherently about it.
Depending on where that goes, you should get pgsql-hackers involved.
[dmb>] Love to. It takes time to learn the "culture of the lists" too.
Regards
David M Bennett FACS
Andl - A New Database Language - andl.org
